Comparisons · November 22, 2026 · 9 min read
Is Russell Stover Healthier Than Whitman's? Both Use Red 40
Per 2 pieces, Russell Stover (33g) lists 150 calories and Whitman's (26g) 120; both boxes list Red 40, Yellow 5 & 6, Blue 1 & 2 and carmine.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 22, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

The Russell Stover Assorted Chocolates 9.4 oz box and the Whitman's Sampler Assorted 10 oz box list different piece counts, serving sizes, and ingredient lists, so their label numbers cannot be read as like-for-like. Both printed ingredient lists name FD&C Red 40, Yellow 5 and 6, Blue 1 and 2, and carmine color. This page sets the printed label facts side by side so you can compare them on the criteria you care about.
Key takeaways
- Serving sizes differ: the label photos show 2 pieces (33 g) for Russell Stover and 2 pieces (26 g) for Whitman's, so per-serving figures are not directly comparable.
- The brand pages and label photos report different calories, sugar, and serving counts for both boxes.
- Both ingredient lists name FD&C Red 40, Yellow 5 and 6, Blue 1 and 2, and carmine color.
- The allergen lines differ mainly on cashews, and the ingredient lists name different fats and syrups.
- FDA says color additives and carmine/cochineal extract must be named on food labels, so the printed ingredient list is the most direct check.
At a glance, using the Russell Stover Assorted Chocolates brand page, the Whitman's Sampler brand page, and the Open Food Facts label photos for Russell Stover and Whitman's. Each row names its source:
| Label item | Russell Stover 9.4 oz (UPC 077260044006) | Whitman's Sampler 10 oz (UPC 076740070665) |
|---|---|---|
| Pieces per box | 16 | 22 |
| Serving size (label photo) | 2 pieces (33 g) | 2 pieces (26 g) |
| Servings per box (label photo) | About 8 | About 11 |
| Calories, brand page | 150 (no serving size shown) | 110 (serving size shown as "26", no unit) |
| Calories, label photo | 150 per serving | 120 per serving |
| Total sugars, label photo | 16 g | 14 g |
| Added sugars, label photo | 15 g (30% DV) | 13 g (26% DV) |
| Sodium, brand page | 40 mg (2%) | 30 mg (1%) |
| Red 40 in ingredient list | Yes (FD&C colors and cherries) | Yes (FD&C colors) |
| Carmine in ingredient list | Yes | Yes |
| Cashews in allergen line | Yes | Not listed |
| Hydrogenated oil named | Not named in the ingredient list | Yes, in the peanut butter |
| Gluten-free, kosher, or vegan status | Not disclosed | Not disclosed |
Which Box Is Higher in Calories Per Serving: Russell Stover 9.4 oz or Whitman's 10 oz?
Russell Stover shows the higher calorie figure per serving on both sources: 150 calories per 2 pieces on its label photo and 150 on its brand page, compared with 120 per 2 pieces on the Whitman's label photo and 110 on the Whitman's brand page. The serving sizes are not the same, so the gap reflects both the size of the serving and the calories in it.
The Whitman's brand page shows a serving size of "26" with no unit and about 11 servings, while its label photo shows 2 pieces (26 g) and about 11 servings. The Russell Stover brand page shows no serving size at all, and its label photo shows 2 pieces (33 g) and about 8 servings. Neither source explains why the brand page and the label photo differ for either box. Calories per full box are not stated on either source.
Is Russell Stover chocolate healthy?
The labels do not establish whether either box is healthy for any particular person, because a Nutrition Facts panel describes one serving and not a whole diet. On the brand pages, Russell Stover lists 4.5 g of saturated fat (23%) and 40 mg of sodium (2%) per serving, while Whitman's lists 3 g (15%) and 30 mg (1%). Those are the printed figures, and the Nutrition Facts panel on the box you hold is the place to check the serving you would actually eat.
A label describes one serving and cannot show how any individual responds to calories, sugar, dyes, or allergens.
How Much Added Sugar Is on the Russell Stover and Whitman's Sampler Labels?
The label photos show 15 g of added sugars (30% Daily Value) per 2-piece serving of Russell Stover and 13 g (26%) per 2-piece serving of Whitman's. The brand pages show 13 g (26%) for Russell Stover and 13 g (25%) for Whitman's.
Total sugars follow a similar pattern on the label photos, at 16 g for Russell Stover and 14 g for Whitman's per serving. The brand page lists total sugar at 15 g for Russell Stover and 13 g for Whitman's. Because the Russell Stover serving is 33 g and the Whitman's serving is 26 g, a sugar figure per serving is not the same as a sugar figure per gram or per piece.
Neither page explains why the Russell Stover added sugar figure is 13 g on the brand page and 15 g on the label photo. Anyone tracking added sugar should use the Nutrition Facts panel printed on the box they buy, since that panel reflects the specific box in hand.
Which Red 40 and Other Synthetic Dyes Are Listed on Each Box?
Both ingredient lists name FD&C Red 40, Yellow 5 and 6, and Blue 1 and 2 under FD&C colors. Russell Stover also lists FD&C Red 40 inside its cherries, so Red 40 appears in two places in its printed ingredient text.
In the Whitman's list, Red 40 appears only within the FD&C colors group. Both lists also include sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate as preservatives, which are not colors but appear on both ingredient statements.
Which specific pieces contain these dyes, carmine, or peanuts is not disclosed on either brand page or label photo. A shopper who needs to avoid a particular color cannot tell from the box which filling carries it, so the ingredient statement only confirms what is in the box as a whole. For other candy label comparisons that name Red 40, see Does Twizzlers Have Red Dye 40? Twizzlers vs Red Vines or Brach's vs Spangler Candy Canes: Both Use Red 40.
Is Carmine Listed on the Russell Stover and Whitman's Sampler Ingredients?
Yes, both printed ingredient lists name CARMINE COLOR. Neither brand page says which pieces contain it, so the ingredient text confirms carmine for the box as a whole rather than for any single piece.
Carmine is one of the ingredients that FDA requires to be named on the label, which is why it appears by name on both lists. Shoppers who avoid carmine can use the ingredient statement as the check, and should read it on the specific box in hand, because the two brand pages and label photos already show that printed details can differ.
What Allergens Does Each Box Label Declare, and Where Do They Differ?
The Russell Stover allergen line reads MILK, SOY, PEANUTS, CASHEWS, ALMONDS, PECANS, EGG, WALNUTS, COCONUT. The Whitman's contains statement reads Milk, Soy, Peanuts, Coconut, Almonds, Walnuts, Pecans and Egg. The main difference in the declared lists is cashews, which appear only on the Russell Stover line.
Both boxes declare milk, soy, peanuts, almonds, pecans, egg, walnuts, and coconut. The ingredient text adds detail beyond the allergen line: Russell Stover includes cashews and high fructose corn syrup in its ingredient list, while Whitman's includes peanut butter made with hydrogenated cottonseed/rapeseed oil and soy oil. Only the Russell Stover list names cashews, and only the Whitman's list names hydrogenated cottonseed/rapeseed oil.
Cross-contact statements beyond the listed allergens, and whether the two boxes are made on the same line or in the same plant, were not disclosed on either source.
Is Russell Stover candy gluten free?
Gluten-free status was not disclosed on the Russell Stover brand page or label photo. Neither page states gluten-free, kosher, or vegan status for either box, so a shopper with those needs should look for a statement printed on the box or on the maker's own materials.
Why Do the Serving Sizes and Piece Counts Make Side-by-Side Comparison Tricky?
Russell Stover's box has 16 pieces and Whitman's has 22. The label photos define a serving as 2 pieces for both, but at different weights: 33 g and 26 g. Two pieces of Russell Stover are about one-eighth of the box, while two pieces of Whitman's are about one-eleventh, so a per-serving number describes different shares of each box.
The brand pages make the comparison harder. Russell Stover's brand page shows no serving size, and Whitman's shows "26" with no unit. Servings per box also vary by source: about 9 on the Russell Stover brand page and about 8 on its label photo, while Whitman's shows about 11 on both sources.
For a shopper, this means the per-serving calorie and sugar figures should be read next to the serving size printed on the same panel, not compared across brands from memory.
What Do FDA Rules Require Each Box Label to Name for Dyes and Carmine?
FDA's consumer questions and answers page says a label "must list the names of any FDA-certified color additive (e.g., FD&C Blue No. 1 or the abbreviated name, Blue 1)." For these two boxes, that rule is why the FD&C color names appear in the ingredient statements by name.
On carmine, the same FDA page states: "Because of potential allergic reactions in some people, carmine/cochineal extract are required to be identified by name on food labels." (Color Additives Questions and Answers for Consumers, FDA)
These statements describe labeling requirements. They do not show how any color affects a particular person, and neither brand page shows which piece in either box carries a color. The printed ingredient list is therefore the most direct check on the box in hand.
How Can Shoppers Check the Label on the Box in Hand Before Buying?
Start with the serving size, then read the ingredient statement, then the contains line. The same calorie number can describe a different amount of chocolate depending on the serving, so the serving line comes first.
- Find the serving size and servings per container, and note whether the serving is given in grams, pieces, or both.
- Read the FD&C color names, and look for carmine or cochineal extract by name.
- Check the ingredient list for cashews, hydrogenated oils, and high fructose corn syrup, since those differ between these two brand pages.
- Read the contains line, and look for any cross-contact wording printed on the box.
- Compare the brand page with the box, because the brand pages and label photos differ for both products.
Is Russell Stover real chocolate?
The ingredient text lists milk chocolate and dark chocolate components, each with its own sub-ingredient list, so the label names chocolate as an ingredient. The cacao percentage of either chocolate was not disclosed, so the labels cannot show how much of either piece is cocoa.
Does Russell Stover use real chocolate?
The brand page names chocolate components in its milk chocolate listing, including cocoa butter and chocolate, which is what the label discloses. Whether that matches a specific definition of real chocolate is not addressed on the brand page, and the cacao percentage was not disclosed.
Common questions
- Is Russell Stover or Whitman's better?
- The label facts do not establish a winner. The boxes differ in piece count (16 vs 22), serving size (2 pieces at 33 g vs 2 pieces at 26 g), and ingredient lists, so the label numbers cannot be read as like-for-like.
- Is Russell Stover real chocolate?
- The ingredient text lists milk chocolate and dark chocolate components, but the cacao percentage of either chocolate was not disclosed on the brand page or label photo.
- Does Russell Stover use real chocolate?
- The label names milk chocolate and dark chocolate components, but whether that meets a given definition of real chocolate is not addressed on the brand page, and the cacao percentage was not disclosed.
- Is Russell Stover chocolate healthy?
- The labels do not establish whether either box is healthy for a particular person, because they show one serving only, such as 150 calories and 13 g of added sugars per serving on the Russell Stover brand page.
- Is Whitman's chocolate still in business?
- The Russell Stover website has a current product page for the Whitman's Sampler 10 oz box (UPC 076740070665); that page does not describe company ownership.
- Is Russell Stover candy gluten free?
- Gluten-free status was not disclosed on the Russell Stover brand page or label photo for this box, so the printed label is the place to look.
- Does Whitman's Sampler have Red 40?
- Yes, the brand page ingredient list names FD&C Red 40 within FD&C colors alongside Yellow 5 and 6 and Blue 1 and 2, but which pieces contain it was not disclosed.
Sources
- Color Additives Questions and Answers for Consumers (fda.gov)
- Russell Stover Assorted Chocolates 9.4 oz Box (russellstover.com)
- Whitman's Sampler Assorted Milk & Dark Chocolate Candy Gift Box, 10 oz (russellstover.com)
- Open Food Facts: Russell Stover Assorted Chocolates (UPC 0077260044006) (world.openfoodfacts.org)
- Open Food Facts: Whitman's Sampler Assorted (UPC 0076740070665) (world.openfoodfacts.org)
In this series
Guide
What to Buy Instead of Hot Cheetos: 5 Label SwapsGuide
Which Mint Lists Dyes, Andes or York Peppermint Patty?Guide
Do Lofthouse Cookies Have Red 40? Lofthouse vs PillsburyGuide
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateGuide
Does Cherry Pie Filling Have Red Dye? Comstock vs Lucky LeafGuide
Are Sprinkles Made With Red 40? Betty Crocker, ColorKitchen
Related guides
Guides
We Read 30 Christmas Candy Labels: 19 List Red 40We read 30 US Christmas candy labels: 20 list FD&C dyes, 19 list Red 40, 3 use fruit or vegetable color and 7 add no color. Every product and its label listed.
Comparisons
Do Lofthouse Cookies Have Red 40? Lofthouse vs PillsburyLofthouse Holiday cookies list six colors including Red 40 and Red 40 Lake; Pillsbury's Christmas Tree dough lists Red 40, Yellow 5 & 6 and Blue 1.
Comparisons
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateLittle Debbie's vanilla tree cakes list Red 40 Lake; the chocolate ones list Red 40 Lake and Red 40. Each is 220 calories per 49 g cake.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy