Comparisons · November 20, 2026 · 8 min read
Do Lofthouse Cookies Have Red 40? Lofthouse vs Pillsbury
Lofthouse Holiday cookies list six colors including Red 40 and Red 40 Lake; Pillsbury's Christmas Tree dough lists Red 40, Yellow 5 & 6 and Blue 1.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 20, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies and Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough both list Red 40, but they differ in their other named colors, their Contains lines, and their added sugar figures.
Both labels name Red 40, but the full color lists differ. Lofthouse lists six color entries (Red 40, Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake, Blue 1, and Blue 1 Lake) plus a separate annatto color. Pillsbury lists Yellow 5 & 6, Blue 1, and Red 40. Lofthouse's Contains line names egg, milk, soy, and wheat, while Pillsbury's allergen line names wheat and egg only. This page puts the label facts side by side so you can compare them yourself.
Key takeaways
- Lofthouse lists Red 40, Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake, Blue 1, and Blue 1 Lake under Colors, plus annatto as a color. Pillsbury lists Yellow 5 & 6, Blue 1, and Red 40.
- Lofthouse's Contains line reads egg, milk, soy, wheat. Pillsbury's allergen line reads wheat and egg, and its ingredient list does not name milk.
- Lofthouse shows 16 g added sugars per 1 cookie (31% DV). Pillsbury shows 9 g per 2 cookies (17% DV). The serving sizes differ, so compare with care.
- FDA lists FD&C Red No. 40, Blue No. 1, Yellow No. 5, and Yellow No. 6 among the nine certified color additives approved for food use. That listing does not rate either product.
- Dye amounts, gram weights per cookie, and Pillsbury's facility and dairy status beyond the listed ingredients are not disclosed on these labels.
Are Lofthouse and Pillsbury Christmas Cookies Both Made With Red 40?
Yes. The Lofthouse label lists Red 40 and Red 40 Lake for a serving of 1 cookie, and the Pillsbury label lists Red 40 in its ingredient statement for a serving of 2 cookies. On both labels the colors sit inside a 'Contains 2% or less of' grouping, but neither label gives an amount for any dye.
| Label fact | Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies | Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough |
|---|---|---|
| Red 40 listed | Yes (Red 40 and Red 40 Lake) | Yes |
| Other colors listed | Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake, Blue 1, Blue 1 Lake, annatto | Yellow 5 & 6, Blue 1 |
| Milk | Nonfat Milk in ingredients; Contains: milk | Not named in ingredients or allergen line |
| Egg | Eggs in ingredients; Contains: egg | Eggs in ingredients; allergen line: egg |
| Soy | Contains: soy | Not named in allergen line |
| Serving size | 1 cookie (10 servings) | 2 cookies (10 servings) |
| Added sugars | 16 g (31% DV) | 9 g (17% DV) |
Do Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies Have Red 40 and Other Dyes?
Yes. For a serving of 1 cookie, the Colors entry lists Red 40 and Red 40 Lake along with Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake, Blue 1, and Blue 1 Lake. The ingredient statement also lists Annatto [Color] within the margarine. The label gives no gram weight per cookie and no amount for any individual dye.
Lofthouse is sold as a 10 ct, 13.5 oz package, with the manufacturer listed as TreeHouse Private Brands, Inc., per the Stop & Shop product page: Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies - 10 ct (Stop & Shop). Because the color entries are listed by name without quantities, the label supports a statement about which colors are present, but not about how much of each one a cookie contains.
For a separate side-by-side on colors and sugar from another Pillsbury product, see Pillsbury vs Betty Crocker Frosting: Colors and Sugar.
Do Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough Have Red 40 and Other Dyes?
Yes. The ingredient list names Yellow 5 & 6, Blue 1, and Red 40 under 'Contains 2% or less of,' alongside Artificial Flavor. The label does not name lake forms for any of these colors and does not list annatto. The product is one 9.1 oz tray that makes 20 cookies, and the nutrition panel is based on a serving of 2 cookies, per the Pillsbury product page: Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough.
Yellow 6 appears on the Pillsbury label and does not appear on the Lofthouse label. Lofthouse lists lake forms and annatto, which Pillsbury does not list. Neither label discloses how much of any dye either product contains.
For context on a holiday product that also uses Red 40, see Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs Chocolate.
Do Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies Have Dairy?
Yes. Per 1 cookie (serving size), the label lists Nonfat Milk in the ingredient statement, and the Warnings line reads 'Contains: egg, milk, soy, wheat.' The cookies are not labeled dairy free.
The margarine is listed with palm oil, water, soybean oil, and salt. The figures in this section come from the Stop & Shop product page for the 10 ct package.
Does Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough Have Dairy?
No milk, butter, or cream is named in the ingredient list for the Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough, which the nutrition panel describes per serving of 2 cookies. The allergen line reads 'CONTAINS WHEAT AND EGG INGREDIENTS,' and milk is not named there.
The page gives no may-contain statement and no dairy-free claim. Whether the dough is dairy free, or whether it is made in a facility that handles milk, is not disclosed. Readers who need that answer should check the package or contact the manufacturer.
Do Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies Contain Egg?
Yes. Eggs are listed in the ingredient statement, and the Contains line names egg, for a serving of 1 cookie. The label does not give an egg amount.
Pillsbury also lists eggs under 'Contains 2% or less of,' and its allergen line names egg. According to the Pillsbury product page, the dough is made with pasteurized eggs and heat-treated flour. That is a claim made by the brand, and it is presented here as the brand's statement rather than an independent finding.
Are Lofthouse Cookies Nut Free?
No nut ingredient is listed, but the label is not a nut-free claim: it says 'Made in a peanut & tree nut free facility.' That is a facility statement, not a nut-free product claim, so the label does not describe the cookies as nut free.
For Pillsbury, the ingredient text lists no nut ingredient, but it gives no facility statement, so nut status is not disclosed. Readers with nut allergies should read the full package label and contact the manufacturer when a statement is missing.
How Much Added Sugar Is in Lofthouse vs Pillsbury Christmas Tree Cookies?
Lofthouse lists 16 g of added sugars per 1 cookie, which is 31% Daily Value, and 16 g total sugars. Pillsbury lists 9 g of added sugars per 2 cookies, which is 17% Daily Value, and 9 g total sugars.
The serving sizes differ, and neither label gives a gram weight per cookie, so the labels do not support an exact per-cookie comparison. The products also differ in form: one is frosted and one is unfrosted dough. Calories per labeled serving are 160 for one Lofthouse cookie and 110 for two Pillsbury cookies. Compare the Daily Value figures and the labeled serving sizes as printed rather than converting one serving into another.
What Are the Pillsbury Christmas Tree Cookies Ingredients?
The ingredient statement lists the following, in order:
- Enriched flour bleached (wheat flour, niacin, iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid)
- Sugar
- Palm oil
- Water
- Canola oil
- Contains 2% or less of: eggs, baking powder (sodium aluminum phosphate, baking soda), salt, artificial flavor, Yellow 5 & 6, Blue 1, Red 40, and sodium benzoate (preservative)
The list does not name milk, butter, or cream. Each entry is shown as the label prints it, and the label gives no amount for any ingredient beyond the 2% grouping.
What Do the Contains Lines Say on Each Label?
The Lofthouse Warnings line reads 'Contains: egg, milk, soy, wheat.' The Pillsbury allergen line reads 'CONTAINS WHEAT AND EGG INGREDIENTS.' The two lines overlap on wheat and egg. Lofthouse adds milk and soy, and soy also appears in its ingredient list as soy lecithin.
A Contains line lists the allergen sources the manufacturer chose to name. It does not state how much of an allergen is present, and it is not a statement about cross-contact. Readers who manage allergies should read the full ingredient list and any facility statement on the package they buy.
Are Food Dyes in These Cookies Regulated by the FDA?
The FDA lists FD&C Blue No. 1, FD&C Red No. 40, FD&C Yellow No. 5, and FD&C Yellow No. 6 among the nine certified color additives approved for use in food. The FDA's consumer questions and answers on color additives are here: Color Additives: Questions and Answers for Consumers.
That approval describes the regulatory status of the colors. It does not measure how much dye is in either product, and it does not rate either cookie as safer or less safe than the other.
Neither label discloses how much of any dye the product contains.
For another holiday Red 40 comparison, see Brach's vs Spangler Candy Canes: Both Use Red 40.
How to Read These Labels to Compare Dyes, Allergens, and Sugar Yourself
Start with the ingredient statement and find the color entries. Note whether each color is listed in the main ingredients or under a 'Contains 2% or less of' grouping, and whether lake forms are named.
- Check the Contains or allergen line, then search the full ingredient list for milk, egg, soy, nut, and wheat terms.
- Look for a facility statement such as 'Made in a peanut & tree nut free facility' and note whether a may-contain line appears.
- Read the Nutrition Facts panel first for the serving size, then compare added sugars per labeled serving.
- Do not divide one product's serving into another's serving without a labeled gram weight.
- Compare the same package size and version you plan to buy.
The labels in this comparison come from the Stop & Shop product page and the Pillsbury product page, so the package in your kitchen is the final source. If a detail is missing from both, treat it as not disclosed rather than assuming an answer.
Common questions
- Do Lofthouse cookies have dairy?
- Yes. The Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies label lists Nonfat Milk in the ingredients and reads 'Contains: egg, milk, soy, wheat,' for a serving of 1 cookie.
- Do Lofthouse cookies have eggs?
- Yes. Eggs appear in the Lofthouse ingredient statement, and the Contains line names egg, for a labeled serving of 1 cookie.
- Do Lofthouse cookies have nuts?
- No nut ingredient is listed. The label says the cookies are made in a peanut and tree nut free facility, which is a facility statement and not a nut-free product claim.
- Do Lofthouse cookies have sour cream?
- No sour cream is listed in the ingredients or in the Contains line for Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies.
- Are Lofthouse cookies dairy free?
- No. The label lists Nonfat Milk as an ingredient and includes milk in its Contains line, so the label does not describe these cookies as dairy free.
- Do Pillsbury sugar cookies have dairy?
- The Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough ingredient list does not name milk, and the allergen line reads 'CONTAINS WHEAT AND EGG INGREDIENTS.' Whether it is dairy free or made in a facility that handles milk is not disclosed.
- Does Red 40 appear in both Lofthouse and Pillsbury cookies?
- Yes. Lofthouse lists Red 40 and Red 40 Lake for a 1 cookie serving, and Pillsbury lists Red 40 in its ingredient statement for a 2 cookie serving. Neither label gives an amount.
Sources
- Color Additives: Questions and Answers for Consumers (fda.gov)
- Lofthouse Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookies, 10 ct, 13.5 oz pkg (stopandshop.com)
- Pillsbury Shape Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Dough (pillsbury.com)
- Understanding How the FDA Regulates Color Additives (fda.gov)
- Have Food Allergies? Read the Label (fda.gov)
- How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)
In this series
Guide
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateGuide
Does Cherry Pie Filling Have Red Dye? Comstock vs Lucky LeafGuide
Are Sprinkles Made With Red 40? Betty Crocker, ColorKitchenGuide
Is There Gelatin in Jell-O? Jell-O vs Simply Delish JelGuide
Are Sour Patch Kids Vegan? No Gelatin, Like Swedish FishGuide
Do Dum Dums Have Red 40? 4 Dyes vs YumEarth Organic Pops
Related guides
Comparisons
Which Mint Lists Dyes, Andes or York Peppermint Patty?York's ingredient list names no colors; Andes Creme de Menthe lists 'Color Added', and its holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake.
Guides
What to Buy Instead of Hot Cheetos: 5 Label SwapsCheetos Simply NKD Flamin' Hot drops Red 40 and lists 140 mg sodium vs 210 mg; four more Hot Cheetos swaps change fat, color source, dairy or protein.
Comparisons
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateLittle Debbie's vanilla tree cakes list Red 40 Lake; the chocolate ones list Red 40 Lake and Red 40. Each is 220 calories per 49 g cake.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy