Comparisons · November 21, 2026 · 8 min read
Which Mint Lists Dyes, Andes or York Peppermint Patty?
York's ingredient list names no colors; Andes Creme de Menthe lists 'Color Added', and its holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 21, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Andes Crème de Menthe Thins and York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties differ on several label facts. The standard Andes box lists 'Color Added' without naming the colors, the Andes Holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake, and Hershey's York ingredient list names no color. Per serving, the labels show different sugar, fat, and allergen statements, which the sections below set side by side.
Key takeaways
- The standard Andes label lists 'Color Added' without naming the colors. The Andes Holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake.
- Hershey's York ingredient list names no color.
- Per serving, Andes lists 5 g total sugars and 4 g added sugars per 2 pieces (9 g). York lists 26 g total sugars and 26 g added sugars per 39 g package.
- Andes says 'May contain Milk or Soy.' York says 'Contains: Egg, Milk, Soy.'
Do Andes Creme de Menthe Thins Have Dye?
Yes, the standard Andes Crème de Menthe label lists 'Color Added' in its ingredient statement, and the Andes Crème de Menthe Holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake.
The standard box's Nutrition Facts panel is listed for UPC 041186000415, with 14 servings per container and a serving of 2 pieces (9 g). The ingredient text includes Natural Mint Flavor, Color Added, and Natural and Artificial Flavor. Tootsie's product page does not name the colors behind 'Color Added,' so the colors on the regular box are not disclosed.
The Holiday bag uses different wording. Its ingredient text reads 'colors added (yellow 5 lake, blue 1 lake),' and it lists peppermint oil where the standard label lists Natural Mint Flavor. The amount of each color is not disclosed on either page.
Do York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties Have Dye?
Hershey's ingredient list for YORK Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties, 1.4 oz names no color additive.
The ingredients listed are Sugar, Corn Syrup, Chocolate, Cocoa, Invert Syrup, Milk Fat, Egg Whites, Cocoa Butter, Lecithin (Soy), Oil of Peppermint, PGPR, and Natural Flavors. Oil of Peppermint and Natural Flavors are flavor terms, and the ingredient text does not name a color under them.
Hershey's page notes: 'Always refer to each package for current ingredients and allergen statements.' The York details here cover the 1.4 oz package only, and Hershey's 1.4 oz page does not give ingredients for other sizes.
How Do Andes and York Compare on Sugar Per Serving?
Per serving, the standard Andes label lists 5 g total sugars and 4 g added sugars for 2 pieces (9 g), while York lists 26 g total sugars and 26 g added sugars for one 39 g package. The added sugars line shows 8% Daily Value for Andes and 52% for York.
The Andes Holiday bag reports the same 5 g total and 4 g added sugars, but its serving is 1 piece (9 g). Because the serving sizes differ, a per-piece figure and a per-package figure measure different amounts. For York, the single package is the serving, so the 26 g figure describes the entire 39 g candy.
The sweeteners named in the ingredient text also differ. York lists sugar, corn syrup, and invert syrup. Andes lists sugar, and the Holiday bag also lists lactose. Readers who want a second candy comparison on dyes and sugar can read Brach's vs Spangler Candy Canes: Both Use Red 40.
How Do Andes and York Compare on Fats Per Serving?
Per serving, the standard Andes label lists 3 g total fat and 2.5 g saturated fat for 2 pieces (9 g), while York lists 2.5 g total fat and 1.5 g saturated fat for one 39 g package. The Daily Value percentages are 4% and 13% for Andes, and 3% and 8% for York.
The fat sources in the ingredient text differ. Andes lists palm kernel and palm oil, nonfat dry milk powder, and soy lecithin. York lists chocolate, milk fat, cocoa butter, and lecithin (soy), along with PGPR, which Hershey's page lists without further explanation.
Cholesterol is listed as 0 mg on the standard Andes panel and on the York panel. Trans fat is listed as 0 g on the standard Andes panel, while Hershey's York panel shows no trans fat line. The Holiday bag lists the same 3 g total fat and 2.5 g saturated fat per 1 piece.
Readers who track saturated fat can compare the 2.5 g and 1.5 g figures directly. The labels do not say how much fat fits any individual's needs, and this article does not offer that guidance.
What Do the Contains and Allergen Lines Say on Each Label?
The standard Andes label says 'May contain Milk or Soy,' while the York label says 'Contains: Egg, Milk, Soy.' The York line names egg, and the Andes lines do not.
- Andes Crème de Menthe Thins: 'May contain Milk or Soy.' The page badges read Gluten Free and Peanut Free. The label also states it 'Contains a bioengineered food ingredient made from U.S. crops.'
- Andes Crème de Menthe Holiday bag: 'May contain Milk or Soy.' The ingredient text includes nonfat milk, lactose, milk protein concentrate, and soy lecithin. Its page badges also read Gluten Free and Peanut Free.
- York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties: 'Contains: Egg, Milk, Soy.' The dietary icons read OU-D and GLUTEN FREE. Hershey's page does not state bioengineered status.
Hershey's York page shows no peanut icon, so this article does not state York's peanut status. FDA's Have Food Allergies? Read the Label page covers allergen labeling in general. Neither brand page explains what 'May contain' means for its production.
What Are Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake, and Where Does the FDA Stand?
FDA lists FD&C Blue No. 1 and FD&C Yellow No. 5 among the nine certified color additives approved for food, and it states that certified color additives are synthetic colorings.
The Andes Holiday label uses the names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake. Tootsie's page does not explain how the lake form differs from other forms. FDA's list of uses for these colors includes confections.
FDA's consumer questions page includes this line: "Parents who wish to limit the amount of color additives in their children’s diet may check the food ingredient list on labels." The source is Color Additives: Questions and Answers for Consumers, published by FDA.
The Andes labels do not disclose the amount of each color.
How Do the Serving Sizes Change the Comparison?
The two Andes labels define servings differently: the standard box lists 14 servings of 2 pieces (9 g), and the Holiday bag lists 24 servings of 1 piece (9 g). York lists one serving as the full 1.4 oz (39 g) package, with 1 serving per container.
Because of these differences, the York figure of 26 g total sugars describes a whole package, while the Andes figures describe a smaller piece count. Comparing the panels line by line is most accurate when the serving sizes are noted beside each number.
Tootsie's pages do not explain why the Holiday label lists 1 piece (9 g) while the regular box lists 2 pieces (9 g), and Hershey's 1.4 oz page gives York nutrition for that size only. Readers interested in how other holiday treats list color can read Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs Chocolate.
Andes vs York at a Glance: Which Label Facts Differ?
The main differences on these labels are the named colors, sugar and fat per serving, allergen wording, and serving size. The table below lists each fact as printed in the panels and ingredient text quoted above.
| Label fact | Andes Crème de Menthe Thins (standard) | Andes Crème de Menthe Holiday bag | York Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties (1.4 oz) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Serving size | 2 pieces (9 g) | 1 piece (9 g) | 1 package (39 g) |
| Servings per container | 14 | 24 | 1 |
| Calories | 50 | 50 | 150 |
| Total fat | 3 g (4%) | 3 g (4%) | 2.5 g (3%) |
| Saturated fat | 2.5 g (13%) | 2.5 g (13%) | 1.5 g (8%) |
| Total sugars | 5 g | 5 g | 26 g |
| Added sugars | 4 g (8%) | 4 g (8%) | 26 g (52%) |
| Color wording | 'Color Added' (colors not named) | Yellow 5 Lake, Blue 1 Lake | No color named |
| Allergen line | May contain Milk or Soy | May contain Milk or Soy | Contains: Egg, Milk, Soy |
| Badges or icons | Gluten Free, Peanut Free | Gluten Free, Peanut Free | OU-D, GLUTEN FREE |
| Protein | 1 g | 0 g | Less than 1 g |
How Can Shoppers Check the Current Label Before Buying?
Shoppers can read the ingredient, allergen, and Nutrition Facts lines on the package in hand, because Hershey's page notes that each package carries current ingredients and allergen statements.
- Find the color line. 'Color Added' alone means the box does not name the colors in that line.
- Check the serving size and servings per container before comparing numbers.
- Compare total and added sugars per serving, along with the Daily Value percentages.
- Read the allergen line, including the difference between 'May contain' and 'Contains' wording.
- Note badges and icons, which are page labels and may differ from the printed package.
These labels cannot show how any individual responds to these colors, sugars, or fats. Labels can change between production runs, so the package in hand is the reference.
Common questions
- Do Andes mints have dye?
- Yes, the standard Andes Crème de Menthe Thins label lists 'Color Added,' and the Andes Holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake. The standard box does not name its colors, and the amount of each color is not disclosed.
- Do Andes mints have artificial dyes?
- The Holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake, and FDA lists FD&C Yellow No. 5 and FD&C Blue No. 1 among its certified color additives, which it calls synthetic colorings. The standard box lists only 'Color Added,' so its colors are not disclosed.
- Are Andes mints dye free?
- Not according to these labels, since both the standard and Holiday versions list added color. The standard label does not name the colors, and the Holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake.
- Do York peppermint patties have dye?
- Hershey's ingredient list for the 1.4 oz YORK Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties names no color additive. Hershey's 1.4 oz page does not give ingredients for other sizes.
- Do York peppermint patties have gelatin?
- Hershey's ingredient list for the 1.4 oz YORK Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties does not list gelatin. The ingredients include Egg Whites, Milk Fat, and Soy lecithin, and Hershey's page does not state the vegan or vegetarian status of the candy.
- Are York peppermint patties healthy?
- The labels do not include a health verdict, and this article does not offer one. The 1.4 oz package lists 150 calories, 2.5 g total fat, 1.5 g saturated fat, 26 g total sugars, and 26 g added sugars per package, which readers can weigh against their own needs.
Sources
- Color Additives: Questions and Answers for Consumers (fda.gov)
- Color Additives History (fda.gov)
- Have Food Allergies? Read the Label (fda.gov)
- Andes Crème de Menthe (Tootsie) (tootsie.com)
- Andes Crème de Menthe Holiday (Tootsie) (tootsie.com)
- YORK Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties, 1.4 oz (hersheyland.com)
In this series
Guide
Do Lofthouse Cookies Have Red 40? Lofthouse vs PillsburyGuide
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateGuide
Does Cherry Pie Filling Have Red Dye? Comstock vs Lucky LeafGuide
Are Sprinkles Made With Red 40? Betty Crocker, ColorKitchenGuide
Is There Gelatin in Jell-O? Jell-O vs Simply Delish JelGuide
Are Sour Patch Kids Vegan? No Gelatin, Like Swedish Fish
Related guides
Guides
What to Buy Instead of Hot Cheetos: 5 Label SwapsCheetos Simply NKD Flamin' Hot drops Red 40 and lists 140 mg sodium vs 210 mg; four more Hot Cheetos swaps change fat, color source, dairy or protein.
Comparisons
Do Lofthouse Cookies Have Red 40? Lofthouse vs PillsburyLofthouse Holiday cookies list six colors including Red 40 and Red 40 Lake; Pillsbury's Christmas Tree dough lists Red 40, Yellow 5 & 6 and Blue 1.
Comparisons
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateLittle Debbie's vanilla tree cakes list Red 40 Lake; the chocolate ones list Red 40 Lake and Red 40. Each is 220 calories per 49 g cake.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy