Comparisons · November 18, 2026 · 8 min read
Does Cherry Pie Filling Have Red Dye? Comstock vs Lucky Leaf
Comstock's current Country Cherry label lists vegetable juice color; Lucky Leaf Cherry lists Red 40. Both list high fructose corn syrup.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 18, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Whether cherry pie filling has red dye depends on the product and the label version. The current Duncan Hines Comstock Original Country Cherry SmartLabel, updated October 13, 2025, lists Vegetable Juice Color and no Red 40, while earlier SmartLabel versions for the same barcode listed Red 40. Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping lists Red 40 color at the end of its ingredient list. Both products list high fructose corn syrup and 100 calories per 1/3 cup.
Key takeaways
- The current Comstock SmartLabel lists Vegetable Juice Color and no Red 40. Earlier SmartLabel versions for the same GTIN (updated March 28, April 24 and May 5, 2025) listed Red 40, so check the label on the can you have.
- Lucky Leaf's cherry filling ingredient list ends with "Red 40 color," and its Premium Cherry page also lists Red 40 Color Added.
- Per 1/3 cup, Comstock (89g) lists 15g added sugars (30% DV) and Lucky Leaf (85g) lists 17g (34% DV). Both list 100 calories and 10mg sodium.
- Both products list high fructose corn syrup in their ingredient lists.
Does Duncan Hines Comstock Original Country Cherry Pie Filling have Red 40?
No, the current Comstock label does not list Red 40 in its ingredient list. The SmartLabel header reads "Information updated on 13-Oct-2025 by Conagra Brands," and it lists Vegetable Juice Color under "Less Than 2% Of."
The full ingredient order on that version is: Cherries, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Modified Food Starch, Less Than 2% Of: Vegetable Juice Color, Citric Acid. The product is listed as NET WT 21 OZ (1 LB 5 OZ) 595g, GTIN 00041255430815.
Does Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling have Red 40?
Yes, the Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping ingredient list ends with "Red 40 color." The full list reads: Cherries, water, high fructose corn syrup, food starch-modified (corn), sugar, citric acid and ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) to maintain color. Red 40 color.
Lucky Leaf's separate Premium Cherry Filling or Topping page lists "Red 40 Color Added" in its ingredients. That page also states the product has "no high fructose corn syrup," and its ingredient list is different from the standard cherry filling. Lucky Leaf's cherry page does not give a reason for using Red 40 or say whether it plans to change it.
Does cherry pie filling have red dye at all? Why the answer depends on the label version
Cherry pie filling can be labeled with Red 40 or with vegetable juice color, and for Comstock the answer depends on which SmartLabel version applies. Lucky Leaf's standard filling lists Red 40 on its product page.
Does Comstock cherry pie filling have Red 40?
Not on the current label, but yes on the earlier SmartLabel versions for the same GTIN. The March 28, 2025 version lists "Cherries, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Modified Food Starch, Red 40, Citric Acid," and the versions updated April 24 and May 5, 2025 also list Red 40. The version updated October 13, 2025 lists Vegetable Juice Color instead.
The SmartLabel does not say when cans with the vegetable-juice-color label reached shelves, so older cans and retailer listings may still show Red 40.
Is Vegetable Juice Color the same as Red 40 on a food label?
No, they are different ingredient names. Red 40 is an FDA-certified color additive, and Vegetable Juice Color is the color line on the current Comstock SmartLabel.
The FDA's Color Additives Questions and Answers for Consumers states that "the label must list the names of any FDA-certified color additive (e.g., FD&C Blue No. 1 or the abbreviated name, Blue 1)," and lists FD&C Red No. 40 among certified colors.
The Comstock SmartLabel does not say which vegetable juices are used for the color. The ingredient list names only Vegetable Juice Color.
Does Comstock cherry pie filling contain high fructose corn syrup, and does Lucky Leaf?
Yes, both products list high fructose corn syrup in the ingredient list. In the Comstock label it appears third, after Cherries and Water. In the Lucky Leaf standard filling it also appears third, after Cherries and water.
Lucky Leaf's Premium Cherry page states "no high fructose corn syrup," and that product's ingredients list Sugar and Food Starch-Modified (Corn) instead. Readers comparing products should match the exact product name and page, since the Premium version is a different listing.
How much added sugar is in 1/3 cup of Comstock vs Lucky Leaf cherry filling?
Comstock lists 15g of added sugars (30% Daily Value) per 1/3 cup, and the Lucky Leaf Nutrition Facts panel lists 17g (34% DV) per 1/3 cup. The Comstock serving is 89g and the Lucky Leaf serving is 85g, so the weights differ slightly.
Total sugars are 18g for Comstock and 20g for Lucky Leaf per 1/3 cup. Total carbohydrate is 23g (8% DV) for Comstock and 25g (9% DV) for Lucky Leaf.
For another side-by-side look at colors and sugar in a baking product, see Pillsbury vs Betty Crocker Frosting: Colors and Sugar.
What are the full ingredient lists for Comstock and Lucky Leaf cherry filling?
The two lists share several ingredients, but the color line differs. The table below uses the current Comstock SmartLabel and the Lucky Leaf product page.
| Item | Duncan Hines Comstock (current SmartLabel) | Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping |
|---|---|---|
| Cherries | Yes, first | Yes, first |
| Water | Yes | Yes |
| High fructose corn syrup | Yes | Yes |
| Starch | Modified Food Starch | Food starch-modified (corn) |
| Sugar | Not listed as a separate item | Yes |
| Citric acid | Yes | Yes |
| Ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) | Not listed | Yes, to maintain color |
| Color | Less Than 2% Of: Vegetable Juice Color | Red 40 color |
The Comstock list is Cherries, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Modified Food Starch, Less Than 2% Of: Vegetable Juice Color, Citric Acid. The Lucky Leaf list is Cherries, water, high fructose corn syrup, food starch-modified (corn), sugar, citric acid and ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) to maintain color. Red 40 color.
How do the calories, sodium, fiber, and potassium compare per 1/3 cup?
Both products list 100 calories and 10mg sodium per 1/3 cup. Lucky Leaf lists more fiber, potassium, and total carbohydrate per serving.
| Nutrient (per 1/3 cup) | Comstock (89g) | Lucky Leaf (85g) |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | 100 | 100 |
| Total Fat | 0g (0%) | 0g (0%) |
| Sodium | 10mg (0%) | 10mg (0%) |
| Total Carbohydrate | 23g (8%) | 25g (9%) |
| Dietary Fiber | Less than 1g (2%) | 1g (4%) |
| Total Sugars | 18g | 20g |
| Added Sugars | 15g (30%) | 17g (34%) |
| Protein | 0g | 0g |
| Potassium | 0mg | 68mg (2%) |
| Calcium | 0mg (0%) | 7mg (0%) |
The Nutrition Facts panel on your package is the official source for these figures, and this comparison does not interpret them as a recommendation for how much to eat.
Do Comstock and Lucky Leaf cherry fillings list allergens or pits to watch for?
The Comstock label states, "This product does not contain any of these common food allergens." It also says, under Health & Safety, "Dear Consumer: An occasional cherry may contain a pit."
The Lucky Leaf Cherry page does not show an allergen statement or a pit statement. Neither the Comstock SmartLabel nor the Lucky Leaf Cherry page states gluten-free status, so it should not be assumed.
People managing allergies should read the current package label rather than an older online listing.
How can you check a cherry filling label for Red 40 and vegetable juice color yourself?
Start with the ingredient list and read the color line at the end, since the Lucky Leaf list places Red 40 color there. Then check for these terms:
- "Red 40" or "FD&C Red No. 40," which FDA requires to be named as a certified color.
- "Vegetable Juice Color," the color line on the current Comstock SmartLabel.
- The SmartLabel header, which shows the update date for Comstock's online label.
Next, compare the Nutrition Facts panel. Check the serving size first, because Comstock uses 89g and Lucky Leaf uses 85g for 1/3 cup. Then look at the Added Sugars line and its percentage.
Finally, compare the package you hold with the manufacturer's product page and any retailer listing. Retailer pages may still show an older label, so the package itself is the most direct source.
Which other cherry and fruit filling comparisons can help you read dye labels?
Several related guides on this site compare how dyes are listed in other products. For a candy example, see Brach's vs Spangler Candy Canes: Both Use Red 40. For a sprinkles example, see Are Sprinkles Made With Red 40? Betty Crocker, ColorKitchen.
This comparison covers what the two labels and the FDA page say. It does not cover health effects of Red 40, vegetable juice color, high fructose corn syrup, or added sugars, and the label facts cannot show how a specific person will react.
Common questions
- Does cherry pie filling have red dye?
- It depends on the product and label version. The current Duncan Hines Comstock Original Country Cherry SmartLabel, updated October 13, 2025, lists Vegetable Juice Color and no Red 40, while Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping lists Red 40 color.
- Does Comstock cherry pie filling have Red 40?
- The current Comstock SmartLabel does not list Red 40, since it lists Vegetable Juice Color instead. Earlier SmartLabel versions for the same GTIN, updated March 28, April 24 and May 5, 2025, list Red 40.
- Is Comstock cherry pie filling gluten free?
- The Comstock SmartLabel does not state gluten-free status. Check the current package label before deciding whether it fits a gluten-free diet.
- Comstock cherry pie filling ingredients?
- The current Comstock SmartLabel lists Cherries, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Modified Food Starch, Less Than 2% Of: Vegetable Juice Color, Citric Acid. Serving size is 1/3 cup (89g).
- Lucky Leaf cherry pie filling ingredients?
- The Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping ingredients are Cherries, water, high fructose corn syrup, food starch-modified (corn), sugar, citric acid and ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) to maintain color, followed by Red 40 color.
- Is cherry pie filling healthy?
- This comparison does not rate whether cherry pie filling is healthy. Both products list 100 calories and 10mg sodium per 1/3 cup, with 15g (Comstock, 89g serving) and 17g (Lucky Leaf, 85g serving) of added sugars, per the brand labels.
- Does Lucky Leaf cherry pie filling have Red 40?
- Yes, the Lucky Leaf Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping ingredient list ends with Red 40 color. Its Premium Cherry page also lists Red 40 Color Added.
Sources
- Duncan Hines Comstock Original Country Cherry Pie Filling & Topping SmartLabel (smartlabel.conagra.com)
- Duncan Hines Comstock Original Country Cherry Pie Filling & Topping SmartLabel, earlier version (smartlabel.conagra.com)
- Cherry Fruit Filling or Topping (luckyleaf.com)
- Premium Cherry Filling or Topping (luckyleaf.com)
- Lucky Leaf Cherry Filling Nutrition Facts (luckyleaf.com)
- Color Additives: Questions and Answers for Consumers (fda.gov)
- Regulatory Status of Color Additives: FD&C Red No. 40 (hfpappexternal.fda.gov)
In this series
Guide
Are Sprinkles Made With Red 40? Betty Crocker, ColorKitchenGuide
Is There Gelatin in Jell-O? Jell-O vs Simply Delish JelGuide
Are Sour Patch Kids Vegan? No Gelatin, Like Swedish FishGuide
Do Dum Dums Have Red 40? 4 Dyes vs YumEarth Organic PopsGuide
Does Twizzlers Have Red Dye 40? Twizzlers vs Red VinesGuide
Brach's vs Spangler Candy Canes: Both Use Red 40
Related guides
Comparisons
Do Lofthouse Cookies Have Red 40? Lofthouse vs PillsburyLofthouse Holiday cookies list six colors including Red 40 and Red 40 Lake; Pillsbury's Christmas Tree dough lists Red 40, Yellow 5 & 6 and Blue 1.
Comparisons
Do Christmas Tree Cakes Have Red 40? Vanilla vs ChocolateLittle Debbie's vanilla tree cakes list Red 40 Lake; the chocolate ones list Red 40 Lake and Red 40. Each is 220 calories per 49 g cake.
Comparisons
Which Mint Lists Dyes, Andes or York Peppermint Patty?York's ingredient list names no colors; Andes Creme de Menthe lists 'Color Added', and its holiday bag names Yellow 5 Lake and Blue 1 Lake.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy