Aurascan

Comparisons · November 14, 2026 · 8 min read

Do Dum Dums Have Red 40? 4 Dyes vs YumEarth Organic Pops

Dum Dums Original Mix lists Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5 and Blue 1; YumEarth Organic Pops are colored with fruit and vegetable concentrates. 9 g vs 8 g sugar per 2 pops.

By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 14, 2026

Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Illustration of a pile of round lollipops beside fresh berries and a sliced beet

Dum Dums Original Mix and YumEarth Organic Vitamin C Pops differ most in where their colors come from. The Dum Dums ingredient list names four certified dyes, Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, and Blue 1, while the YumEarth label says its colors come from organic fruit and vegetable concentrates plus organic turmeric extract. Per 2 pops, the labels list 50 calories and 10 mg of sodium for Dum Dums and 45 calories and 0 mg of sodium for YumEarth, with 9 g and 8 g of added sugar. The label facts are set side by side below.

Key takeaways

  • Dum Dums Original Mix lists Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, and Blue 1 in one ingredient list, and the label does not say which flavor contains which dye.
  • YumEarth Organic Vitamin C Pops list no Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, or Blue 1, and say their colors come from organic fruit and vegetable concentrates plus organic turmeric extract.
  • Per 2 pops, added sugar is 9 g (18% DV) for Dum Dums and 8 g (16% DV) for YumEarth.
  • The Dum Dums allergen statement does not name soy, while the YumEarth product page lists soy among its free-from allergens.

Dum Dums vs YumEarth: Which Dyes Are on the Label?

Dum Dums names four certified dyes by name: Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, and Blue 1. YumEarth names no certified dyes and describes its colors by source, as organic fruit and vegetable concentrates plus organic turmeric extract.

When you compare the color line on each bag, check for three things:

  • Named certified colors, such as Red 40 or Yellow 5.
  • A source phrase, such as 'colored with' followed by a fruit or vegetable concentrate.
  • Whether the label says which flavor carries which color. The Dum Dums label does not.

Does Dum Dums Original Mix Have Red 40 and Other Certified Dyes?

Yes. The Dum Dums Original Mix ingredient list includes Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, and Blue 1, which makes four certified dyes in total.

Spangler Candy Company's brand page lists the ingredients as: 'Sugar, corn syrup, citric acid, malic acid, salt, artificial flavor, color added (includes: Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, Blue 1).' The bag carries one ingredient list for all flavors, so the label does not say which flavor contains which dye. Flavor-level claims on other websites are not confirmed by this label.

Do Dum Dums Have Dye?

Yes. The Original Mix ingredient list ends with 'color added (includes: Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, Blue 1),' which is four certified dyes. The label does not state the amount of any of them.

Do All Dum Dums Have Red Dye?

The label gives one shared ingredient list and does not say which flavor has Red 40. Red 40 appears on that list for the mix, and the flavor-to-dye mapping is not disclosed.

Do Butterscotch Dum Dums Have Red Dye?

Not disclosed. The Original Mix label does not name a butterscotch flavor or assign Red 40 to any flavor, so it does not answer the question for that flavor.

Do YumEarth Vitamin C Pops Use Fruit and Vegetable Colors Instead?

Yes, according to the label text. The back-of-bag ingredients say the pops are 'COLORED WITH ORGANIC FRUIT AND VEGETABLE CONCENTRATES,' and the product page adds 'ORGANIC TURMERIC EXTRACT (COLOR)' at the end of its list. No Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, or Blue 1 is listed.

The product page also states 'No high fructose corn syrup or artificial dyes.' The labels do not say which concentrate colors each flavor, so flavor-by-flavor color sources are not disclosed.

Are YumEarth Lollipops Dye Free?

The YumEarth product page states 'No high fructose corn syrup or artificial dyes,' and no Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, or Blue 1 appears in its ingredient list. The page does not use the phrase dye-free, so its own wording, 'no artificial dyes,' is the statement to quote.

What Do the Certified Color Additives Mean on a Candy Label?

The FDA's Color Additives in Foods page says certified color additives 'are synthetically produced (or human made)' and that there are 'seven certified color additives approved for use in foods.'

On these two labels, the Dum Dums list names each certified color individually (Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, Blue 1), while the YumEarth list describes its colors by source with the words 'colored with.' Neither label states how much color is in each pop.

Is Dum Dums Original Mix Gluten-Free, and What Is in Its Allergen Statement?

Yes. The Dum Dums brand page says 'This product is gluten-free.' Its allergen statement reads: 'This product does not contain peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, wheat, sesame, or gluten. It has been manufactured on dedicated equipment.'

The allergen statement does not name soy, so soy status is not disclosed for Dum Dums. The page says the product was manufactured on dedicated equipment and does not add further detail about the facility.

Do Dum Dums Have Gluten?

The Dum Dums brand page states 'This product is gluten-free,' and its allergen statement lists gluten and wheat among the things the product does not contain.

Do YumEarth Organic Vitamin C Pops Have Soy, Gluten, or Other Top-9 Allergens?

The YumEarth product page lists these as free from: peanuts, gluten, tree nuts, milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, soy, and sesame. The product page does not name wheat, so wheat status is not disclosed there, even though it says the pops are gluten free.

The bag separately says it is 'manufactured in a facility free from peanuts and tree nuts.' That is a facility statement, which is different from the product's free-from list. For the allergens the two brand statements name, the labels compare as follows:

  • Milk, eggs, fish, and shellfish: both labels say the product does not contain them.
  • Peanuts and tree nuts: the Dum Dums statement says the product does not contain them, and the YumEarth product page lists them as free from. The YumEarth bag's facility statement is separate from that product claim.
  • Sesame: both labels say the product does not contain it.
  • Wheat: Dum Dums says it does not contain wheat, and the YumEarth product page does not name wheat.
  • Soy: Dum Dums does not name soy, and YumEarth lists soy as free from.

How Much Added Sugar Is in 2 Dum Dums vs 2 YumEarth Pops?

Per 2 pieces (13 g), Dum Dums Original Mix lists 9 g of added sugars (18% DV). Per 2 pops (12.4 g), YumEarth Organic Vitamin C Pops list 8 g of added sugars (16% DV).

The panels read 'Total Sugars 9g, Incl. 9g Added Sugars' for Dum Dums and 'Total Sugars 8g, Includes 8g Added Sugars' for YumEarth. The first ingredients differ in name: Dum Dums starts with sugar and corn syrup, while YumEarth starts with organic cane sugar and organic brown rice syrup.

Dum Dums vs YumEarth Organic Pops: How Much Sugar per Serving?

The panels list 9 g of added sugar per 2 Dum Dums pieces and 8 g per 2 YumEarth pops, a 1 g difference as printed. The amount of sugar in a single pop is not disclosed, because both labels use a 2-piece or 2-pop serving.

How Do Calories, Sodium, and Serving Size Compare Per 2 Pops?

Per serving, Dum Dums lists 50 calories and YumEarth lists 45 calories, with serving weights of 13 g and 12.4 g.

Sodium is 10 mg (0% DV) for Dum Dums and 0 mg (0% DV) for YumEarth. Total carbohydrate is 13 g (5% DV) for Dum Dums and 11 g (4%) for YumEarth. The YumEarth panel also lists 124 mg of vitamin C (140% DV), which the Dum Dums panel does not list.

Side-by-Side Label Table: Dum Dums vs YumEarth at a Glance

The table below lists the label facts for each product, per 2-piece or 2-pop serving unless noted.

Label itemDum Dums Original MixYumEarth Organic Vitamin C Pops
Serving size2 pieces (13 g)2 pops (12.4 g)
Servings per container7About 7
Calories5045
Sodium10 mg (0% DV)0 mg (0% DV)
Total carbohydrate13 g (5% DV)11 g (4% DV)
Total sugars9 g8 g
Added sugars9 g (18% DV)8 g (16% DV)
Vitamin CNot listed on the panel124 mg (140% DV)
Color sourceCertified dyes: Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, Blue 1Organic fruit and vegetable concentrates, organic turmeric extract
First ingredientsSugar, corn syrupOrganic cane sugar, organic brown rice syrup
GlutenStated as gluten-freeListed as free from; labeled gluten free
SoyNot named in the allergen statementListed as free from
WheatListed as not containedNot named on the product page
Facility statementManufactured on dedicated equipmentManufactured in a facility free from peanuts and tree nuts

What the Labels Cannot Establish

The following items are not disclosed on these labels, so they are left without a value here:

  • Which Dum Dums flavors contain Red 40 or any other dye.
  • Any Spangler timeline for removing artificial dyes from Dum Dums.
  • Whether Dum Dums contains soy, since the allergen statement does not mention it.
  • Sugar per single pop, since both labels use 2-piece or 2-pop servings.
  • Which fruit and vegetable concentrates color each YumEarth flavor.
  • Wheat status on the YumEarth product page.
  • Health effects of Red 40 or other dyes, which this article does not assess.

The YumEarth nutrition figures come from the back-of-bag panel image on the brand's website, so readers should check the package in hand. These label facts cannot show how any individual responds to a dye, allergen, or sugar.

Related Guides for Comparing Dyes in Candy

Readers comparing other candy and snack labels may find these guides useful:

Try Aurascan

See what is really in the food you buy.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Common questions

Do Dum Dums have Red 40?
Yes. The Dum Dums Original Mix ingredient list names Red 40, along with Yellow 6, Yellow 5, and Blue 1. The label does not say which flavor contains which dye.
Do Dum Dums have dye?
Yes, the ingredient list names four certified dyes: Red 40, Yellow 6, Yellow 5, and Blue 1.
Do Dum Dums have artificial dyes?
Yes, the four named colors are certified color additives, and FDA says certified color additives are synthetically produced (or human made). The label lists them under 'color added.'
Do all Dum Dums have red dye?
The label does not say. Red 40 appears on one ingredient list for the Original Mix, and the flavor-to-dye mapping is not disclosed on that label.
Do butterscotch Dum Dums have red dye?
Not disclosed. The Original Mix label does not name a butterscotch flavor or assign Red 40 to any flavor.
Do Dum Dums have gluten?
The brand page states 'This product is gluten-free,' and its allergen statement says the product does not contain gluten.
Are YumEarth lollipops dye free?
The YumEarth product page states 'No high fructose corn syrup or artificial dyes,' and no Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, or Blue 1 is listed. Its colors are described as organic fruit and vegetable concentrates plus organic turmeric extract.

Sources

  1. Dum-Dums Original Mix Lollipops (dumdumpops.com)
  2. Organic Assorted Flavors Vitamin C Lollipops (yumearth.com)
  3. Color Additives in Foods (fda.gov)
  4. Food Allergies (fda.gov)
  5. Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)

In this series

Related guides

Try it on your own groceries

Scan your next label with Aurascan

Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

See a sample result

Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest

An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.

We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy