Comparisons · November 12, 2026 · 7 min read
What's the Difference Between Bays and Thomas' Muffins?
Bays Original lists 450mg sodium per 57g muffin; Thomas' Original lists 240mg per 61g. Ingredients, allergens and preservatives compared.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 12, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Bays Original and Thomas' Original English Muffins are close on calories, fat, and protein, but their labels differ on sodium (450mg vs 240mg per muffin), added sugars, dairy ingredients, and preservatives. Bays lists butter and dry whole milk, while Thomas' lists whey. This comparison places the verified Nutrition Facts and ingredient entries side by side and leaves the decision to you.
Key takeaways
- Per 57g Bays muffin: 450mg sodium (20% DV), 140 calories, 1g added sugars.
- Per 61g Thomas' muffin: 240mg sodium (10% DV), 150 calories, 0g added sugars.
- Bays lists butter and dry whole milk; Thomas' lists whey. Both carry a Milk allergen statement.
- Bays' SmartLabel says Keep Refrigerated; storage details for Thomas' are not covered here.
How do Bays Original and Thomas' Original English Muffins compare at a glance?
Both packages contain six muffins, and both list 5g of protein and 1g of total fat per serving. The sodium, sugar, dairy, and preservative entries are where the two labels differ.
| Label item | Bays Original (per 57g muffin) | Thomas' Original (per 61g muffin) |
|---|---|---|
| Net weight | 12 oz (340g), 6 count | 13 oz (369g), 6 count |
| Calories | 140 | 150 |
| Total fat | 1g (1% DV) | 1g (1% DV) |
| Sodium | 450mg (20% DV) | 240mg (10% DV) |
| Total carbohydrate | 27g (10% DV) | 28g (10% DV) |
| Dietary fiber | 1g (4% DV) | 1g (4% DV) |
| Total sugars | 2g | Less than 1g |
| Added sugars | 1g (2% DV) | 0g (0% DV) |
| Protein | 5g | 5g |
| Calcium | 40mg (4% DV) | 90mg (6% DV) |
| Iron | 0.6mg (4% DV) | 1.6mg (10% DV) |
| Potassium | 80mg (0% DV) | 40mg (0% DV) |
| Dairy ingredients listed | Butter (cream, salt), dry whole milk | Whey |
| Preservatives listed | Sodium propionate, calcium propionate | Calcium propionate, sorbic acid |
| Refrigeration statement | Keep Refrigerated (SmartLabel) | Not covered here |
The packages also differ in weight, with Bays at 340g and Thomas' at 369g. The table reports each brand's own panel without adjusting for the difference in muffin weight.
Which muffin has more sodium per serving, Bays or Thomas'?
Bays Original lists 450mg of sodium per 57g muffin (20% DV), while Thomas' Original lists 240mg per 61g muffin (10% DV). That is a 210mg difference per muffin, and neither brand's disclosed information explains why.
FDA's guide Sodium in Your Diet sets the Daily Value for sodium at less than 2,300 milligrams per day. Its general guide says 5% DV or less of sodium per serving is considered low, and 20% DV or more is considered high. Under that guide, Bays' 20% DV falls in the high category, and Thomas' 10% DV falls between the two cutoffs.
FDA also notes that foods eaten several times a day, such as breads, can add up to a lot of sodium. Bays' FAQ states, 'We do not have a low sodium muffin at this time.' These guidelines are general and do not account for a person's total diet or health needs. For a different sodium comparison, see Which Has More Sodium, Old El Paso or McCormick Taco Mix?.
How do calories and serving size differ between Bays and Thomas' English muffins?
Bays lists 140 calories per 57g muffin, and Thomas' lists 150 calories per 61g muffin. Both packages list six servings.
Open Food Facts lists the same Bays serving (57 g), 140 kcal, 27 g carbohydrate, 2 g sugars, and 5 g protein, which matches the brand's panel. Bays lists 2g total sugars, including 1g added sugars. Thomas' lists under 1g total sugars and 0g added sugars.
Serving size affects how packages compare. The 12 oz Bays package and the 13 oz Thomas' package each contain six muffins, so the per-muffin figures are the most direct comparison on these labels. Neither panel lists calories per gram or per ounce, and this article does not calculate them.
What does each label say about butter, milk, and whey?
Bays lists butter (cream, salt) and dry whole milk, while Thomas' lists whey. Both labels carry a Milk allergen statement, but neither label gives the exact amount of butter, milk, or whey in a muffin.
Bays' SmartLabel places Butter (Cream, Salt) and Dry Whole Milk in its group of ingredients described as 2% or less of each item. Thomas' ingredient list ends with Soy Lecithin, Soy, and Whey.
- Bays Original: butter (cream, salt); dry whole milk; Contains Milk; Chicago Rabbinical Council Dairy certification shown.
- Thomas' Original: whey; Contains Milk; OU Kosher Dairy Certification shown.
Readers who avoid dairy should look at the Milk allergen statement and the ingredient names on the package they buy. Butter, dry whole milk, and whey are all milk-derived ingredients, and this comparison does not establish how any individual will respond to them.
Which preservatives does each English muffin label list, and what do they do?
Bays lists sodium propionate and calcium propionate under preservatives. Thomas' lists calcium propionate and sorbic acid, and its label says these are included to preserve freshness.
Calcium propionate appears on both labels.
- Bays Original: sodium propionate, calcium propionate. No function statement appears for these preservatives.
- Thomas' Original: calcium propionate and sorbic acid, listed as 'To Preserve Freshness.'
- Shared: calcium propionate.
The labels show which preservatives are present but not how much of each is used.
What do the labels say about refrigeration and storage for each brand?
Bays' SmartLabel includes a Keep Refrigerated statement, and Bays says its muffins are refrigerated to maintain freshness and texture. A storage statement or shelf life for Thomas' Original is not covered in this comparison.
Bays' FAQ says, 'Our English muffins are refrigerated in order to maintain not only their freshness, but also the consistently light and crispy texture that English muffin connoisseurs seek.' The Bays product page describes the muffins as pre-sliced and baked from the original Bays family recipe, and it shows 'since 1933.'
Shelf life in days is not covered here for either brand. Shoppers should follow the storage line printed on the package they buy.
How do the allergen and bioengineering declarations differ on each SmartLabel?
Both SmartLabel pages list Contains Milk, Soy, and Wheat, and both carry a USDA Bioengineered declaration. The shared-facility statements differ, with Bays listing Sesame and Thomas' listing Tree Nuts.
Bays' FAQ says its bakery does not use tree nuts or peanuts, and that its muffins contain gluten because they are made with wheat flour. Thomas' SmartLabel states, 'This product contains one or more bioengineered (BE) food ingredients.' The Bays SmartLabel also shows the USDA Bioengineered declaration.
Shared-facility statements describe the manufacturing environment, not an ingredient, and they cannot guarantee that a product is free of an allergen. Readers with sesame or tree nut sensitivities should check the current package and contact the brand directly with questions.
What label details were not disclosed, and how can shoppers check them?
Several comparison points are not stated on either brand's label pages, so this article does not fill them in.
- Why Bays has more sodium than Thomas' (neither brand explains it).
- Whether Thomas' ingredients after a certain point are 2% or less (its SmartLabel shows no such divider).
- Exact amounts of butter, milk, or whey in either muffin.
- Storage instructions and shelf life in days for Thomas' Original.
- Prices, taste, and which muffin tastes better.
- Nutrition for other varieties or pack sizes.
- Any recipe change since the SmartLabel update dates.
To check these details, start with the Nutrition Facts panel and ingredient list on the package you buy. Then open each brand's SmartLabel: Thomas' SmartLabel was updated on 16-Jun-2023 by Thomas', and Bays' SmartLabel was updated on 22-Aug-2022 by Bays. Those dates may not reflect a package printed later. For background on label-scanning apps in the US, read Does Yuka Work in the US? Launched There in January 2022.
These facts describe the label entries printed for these two products at their SmartLabel update dates. They cannot show how either muffin affects any individual, and they do not address specific medical conditions, individual responses, or long-term eating patterns. Open research questions about sodium and bread consumption are outside the scope of this comparison.
Common questions
- Are Bays English muffins better than Thomas English muffins?
- The label facts do not establish that either muffin is better. The labels differ on sodium (450mg vs 240mg per muffin), added sugars (1g vs 0g), dairy ingredients (butter and dry whole milk vs whey), and preservatives.
- Why are Bays English muffins refrigerated?
- Bays says its English muffins are refrigerated to maintain their freshness and the light, crispy texture its customers seek. Its SmartLabel also includes a Keep Refrigerated statement.
- Are Bays English muffins healthy?
- The label alone cannot answer whether a food is healthy for any person. Per 57g muffin, Bays lists 140 calories, 450mg sodium (20% DV), 1g added sugars, and 5g protein.
- Do Thomas English muffins have dairy?
- Yes, the Thomas' Original SmartLabel lists whey as an ingredient and carries a Contains Milk allergen statement. The exact amount of whey in a 61g muffin was not disclosed.
- Do Bays English muffins have preservatives?
- Yes, Bays lists sodium propionate and calcium propionate under preservatives in its SmartLabel ingredient list. The label does not state how much of each is used.
- What is the main difference between Bays and Thomas English muffins?
- The main label differences are sodium (450mg vs 240mg per muffin), muffin weight (57g vs 61g), and dairy ingredients (butter and dry whole milk vs whey). Both brands are distributed by Bimbo Bakeries USA, Inc., Irving, TX.
- Do Thomas English muffins contain tree nuts?
- Tree Nuts appear on the Thomas' SmartLabel as a shared-facility statement, not as an ingredient. Shared-facility statements do not establish whether a specific package contains traces of an allergen.
Sources
- Sodium in Your Diet (fda.gov)
- Thomas' Original English Muffins SmartLabel (smartlabel-bbu.scanbuy.com)
- Bays Original English Muffins SmartLabel (smartlabel-bbu.scanbuy.com)
In this series
Guide
Are Annie's Cinnamon Rolls Healthier Than Pillsbury?Guide
Does Yuka Work in the US? Launched There in January 2022Guide
Which Has More Melatonin, Natrol or OLLY? Both 3mgGuide
Does Jiffy Cornbread Have Lard? Krusteaz Uses Soybean OilGuide
What's the Difference Between Libby's Pumpkin and Pie Mix?Guide
Which Has More Sodium, Old El Paso or McCormick Taco Mix?
Related guides
Comparisons
Which Has More Protein, Lifeway or Maple Hill Kefir?Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10 g protein per 1 cup; Maple Hill Plain Kefir lists 5 g per 2/3 cup. The serving sizes differ, so check both.
Comparisons
Is 4th & Heart Ghee Organic? vs Organic Valley Ghee4th & Heart says it has no organic offering and sources grass-fed butter; Organic Valley ghee is USDA Organic. Ingredient lists and per-serving fat compared.
Comparisons
Is Daisy Healthier Than Breakstone's Sour Cream? 60 Cal EachDaisy lists one ingredient, cultured cream; Breakstone's lists cultured pasteurized cream and enzymes. Both have 60 calories and 3.5 g saturated fat per 2 tbsp.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy