Comparisons · November 20, 2026 · 7 min read
Is 4th & Heart Ghee Organic? vs Organic Valley Ghee
4th & Heart says it has no organic offering and sources grass-fed butter; Organic Valley ghee is USDA Organic. Ingredient lists and per-serving fat compared.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 20, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

4th & Heart Original Ghee and Organic Valley Organic Ghee are both clarified butter products. Both brands' own pages describe their ghee as lactose free and casein free, and the two products differ on organic status, sourcing language, ingredient wording and serving size. Below, the two labels sit side by side in the brands' own words.
Label summary: The label comparison shows that 4th & Heart does not carry an organic claim while Organic Valley does, and that the two per-serving nutrition figures use different serving sizes.
TL;DR: 4th & Heart has no organic offering, Organic Valley's ghee is USDA Certified Organic, both brands claim lactose and casein free, and the serving sizes differ, so the per-serving numbers cannot be compared directly.
Key takeaways
- The 4th & Heart FAQ says the brand has no organic offering and sources grass-fed, pasture-raised butter from Australia and New Zealand. Organic Valley describes its ghee as made from 'USDA Certified Organic butter from Organic Valley's pasture-raised cows.'
- Per serving, 4th & Heart lists 120 calories and 10g saturated fat per 1 Tbsp (13g). Organic Valley lists 45 calories and 3g saturated fat per 1 tsp. The serving sizes differ, and a per-gram comparison is not possible from the brand pages, so readers should not compare these numbers directly.
- Both brands' pages describe their ghee as lactose free and casein free. 4th & Heart still declares milk as an allergen on its packaging, and both ingredient lists name milk.
- The ingredient lists are short: 'Clarified butter (milk).' for 4th & Heart, and organic butterfat, organic butter and lactic acid for Organic Valley.
Is 4th & Heart Original Ghee organic?
No. Answering the question 'Is 4th & Heart ghee organic?', the brand's FAQ says, 'We do not have an organic offering at this time.' It continues, 'Our focus has been on sourcing the finest butter made from grass-fed and pasture-raised cattle.'
Asked whether its ghee is made with milk from grass-fed cows, the FAQ answers, 'We only source Australian and New Zealand grass-fed, pasture-raised butter.' So the brand's own claims for this product are grass-fed and pasture-raised sourcing, not organic certification.
Is Organic Valley Organic Ghee grass-fed?
The brand page says the ghee is made from pasture-raised cows, and it does not state that the ghee is grass-fed or 100% grass-fed. The Organic Valley ghee page says the ghee 'is made from USDA Certified Organic butter from Organic Valley's pasture-raised cows.' That is pasture-raised language, not grass-fed language.
The page does not say whether the ghee comes from 100% grass-fed cows. The organic and pasture-raised wording does not answer the grass-fed question on its own.
Is 4th & Heart Original Ghee casein free?
The 4th & Heart FAQ explains that because the ghee originates from cow's milk, it is declared as an allergen on the packaging, and that 'lactose and casein are removed during the cooking and filtration process.'
Explaining the milk declaration, it adds, 'While our product is lab-tested as lactose and casein free, we feel it is important to remain transparent and notify consumers that our product originates from cow's milk.' The same FAQ says the brand does not source specifically A1 or A2 dairy and does not make a cultured ghee.
Is Organic Valley Organic Ghee lactose free and casein free?
The brand page says its ghee is lactose-free and casein-free. The page states, 'Our ghee is salt-free, lactose-free, and casein-free and is certified Kosher and Halal.' It also describes ghee as 'a lactose-free, casein-free, and shelf-stable product'.
The page does not describe lab testing for this product. The ingredient list still names milk, so the free-of statements describe specific milk components, not the absence of milk as an ingredient.
What are the ingredients in 4th & Heart Original Ghee vs Organic Valley Organic Ghee?
On the 4th & Heart Original Ghee product page, the ingredient list reads 'Clarified butter (milk).' This is a single ingredient, with milk shown in parentheses.
Organic Valley ghee ingredients
The Organic Valley ghee ingredient list reads 'Organic Butterfat (Milk), Organic Butter (Pasteurized Organic Sweet Cream (Milk), Lactic Acid).' The list names organic butterfat, organic butter made from pasteurized organic sweet cream, and lactic acid.
The Organic Valley page does not say what the lactic acid is for or whether the ghee is cultured. 4th & Heart, by contrast, states that it does not make a cultured ghee.
How many calories and saturated fat per serving in each ghee?
Per serving, 4th & Heart lists 120 calories, 13g total fat (17%) and 10g saturated fat (50%) per 1 Tbsp (13g). Organic Valley lists 45 calories, 5g total fat (6%) and 3g saturated fat (15%) per 1 tsp. These serving sizes are different, so the figures describe different amounts of ghee.
Both labels list 0mg sodium, 0g trans fat, 0g total carbohydrate, 0g total sugars, 0g added sugars and 0g protein. Cholesterol is 40mg (13%) for 4th & Heart and 15mg (4%) for Organic Valley. Organic Valley lists 40 mcg vitamin A (4%) per teaspoon, while vitamin A amounts for 4th & Heart were not disclosed. Always check the Nutrition Facts panel on the jar in front of you.
Why do the serving sizes make the two ghees hard to compare?
The two labels use different serving units, a tablespoon for 4th & Heart and a teaspoon for Organic Valley. The gram weight of Organic Valley's 1 tsp serving is not given on the brand page, so the two cannot be compared gram for gram.
Servings per container also vary. The 4th & Heart label photo on Open Food Facts shows a 1 Tbsp (13g) serving and 70 servings per container. Organic Valley's 13 oz jar lists 74 servings and its 7.5 oz jar lists 43 servings. The label photo does not tie the 70 servings to a specific 4th & Heart jar size, so check the jar you buy.
How do 4th & Heart and Organic Valley handle the milk allergen declaration?
4th & Heart says it declares milk as an allergen on its packaging because its ghee originates from cow's milk, even though lactose and casein are removed during processing.
Organic Valley names milk in its ingredient list, in parentheses after organic butterfat and organic butter. Check the jar's own label for its allergen statement.
A lactose or casein claim describes specific milk components. It does not change the fact that milk is an ingredient. Neither brand page says its ghee is safe for people with a milk allergy.
What does the FDA list as major food allergens that include milk?
The FDA's food allergies page lists the major food allergens as 'milk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame.' Milk is the first item on that list.
Because both ghee ingredient lists name milk, the allergen question applies to both products. A lactose or casein statement on a label does not replace reading the milk allergen information on the package.
How do the two ghees compare at a glance?
The table below uses only the label and brand statements described above.
| Label item | 4th & Heart Original Ghee | Organic Valley Organic Ghee |
|---|---|---|
| Organic claim | No organic offering at this time (brand FAQ) | USDA Certified Organic butter (brand page) |
| Sourcing language | Grass-fed, pasture-raised butter from Australia and New Zealand | Pasture-raised cows; 100% grass-fed not disclosed |
| Ingredient list | Clarified butter (milk) | Organic butterfat (milk), organic butter (pasteurized organic sweet cream, milk), lactic acid |
| Serving size | 1 Tbsp (13g) | 1 tsp (gram weight not disclosed) |
| Calories per serving | 120 | 45 |
| Total fat per serving | 13g (17%) | 5g (6%) |
| Saturated fat per serving | 10g (50%) | 3g (15%) |
| Cholesterol per serving | 40mg (13%) | 15mg (4%) |
| Lactose and casein statement | 'Lab-tested as lactose and casein free' (brand FAQ) | 'lactose-free, casein-free' (brand page) |
| Milk allergen declaration | Declared on packaging | Milk named in ingredient list |
| Servings per container | 70 (label photo) | 74 (13 oz); 43 (7.5 oz) |
| Vitamin A per serving | Not disclosed | 40 mcg (4%) |
The label statements here cannot show how any individual person responds to ghee. Labels can change, so the jar in your hand is the final word.
What other label-literacy checks apply to ghee?
A few label checks apply beyond these two brands:
- Confirm the serving size and servings per container before comparing calories.
- Read organic, grass-fed and pasture-raised as separate claims.
- Look for milk in the ingredient list, even when the label says lactose or casein is removed.
- Note whether the label states cultured or not cultured, since the two brands' pages address this differently.
- Check certification lines. 4th & Heart lists Whole30, Keto, Paleo, Non-GMO, Gluten Free and Kosher Dairy certified, and Organic Valley lists Kosher and Halal.
Common questions
- Is 4th and Heart ghee organic?
- The brand says it has no organic offering at this time. Its FAQ says the brand focuses on sourcing butter made from grass-fed and pasture-raised cattle, and it sources Australian and New Zealand grass-fed, pasture-raised butter.
- Is 4th and Heart ghee casein free?
- The brand says its ghee is lab-tested as lactose and casein free, and its FAQ says lactose and casein are removed during the cooking and filtration process. Because the ghee originates from cow's milk, the brand declares milk as an allergen on its packaging.
- Is 4th and Heart ghee A2?
- 4th & Heart says it does not source specifically A1 or A2 dairy, so the brand does not make an A2 claim for this ghee. The brand's FAQ also says it does not make a cultured ghee.
- Is 4th and Heart ghee 100% grass fed?
- The brand's FAQ describes grass-fed, pasture-raised butter sourced from Australia and New Zealand, and says its partner cows are exclusively grass-fed, pasture-raised. The FAQ also says the cows' diets predominantly consist of wild grasses; it does not use the phrase 100% grass-fed.
- Is 4th and Heart ghee cultured?
- No, 4th & Heart says it does not make a cultured ghee. The brand's FAQ addresses this directly, and the Original Recipe Ghee ingredient list reads 'Clarified butter (milk).'
- Is Organic Valley ghee grass fed?
- The brand page says the ghee is made from pasture-raised cows and does not state that it is grass-fed or 100% grass-fed. The page describes the butter as USDA Certified Organic butter from pasture-raised cows, which is pasture-raised language rather than grass-fed language.
Sources
- 4th & Heart Original Ghee (fourthandheart.com)
- 4th & Heart FAQ (fourthandheart.com)
- Open Food Facts product 0853104007860 (world.openfoodfacts.org)
- Organic Valley Ghee (Clarified Butter) (organicvalley.coop)
- Food Allergies (fda.gov)
In this series
Guide
Which Has More Sodium, Cooked Perfect or Farm Rich?Guide
Is Del Monte Healthier Than Green Giant? Both 380mg SodiumGuide
How Does the Bobby Approved App Work? 10 Ingredient RulesGuide
Do Canned Yams Have Added Sugar? Bruce's, Princella: 4gGuide
Is Martinelli's Alcoholic? Martinelli's vs Welch's CiderGuide
Which Has More Sugar, Hood or Organic Valley Eggnog?
Related guides
Comparisons
Which Has More Protein, Lifeway or Maple Hill Kefir?Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10 g protein per 1 cup; Maple Hill Plain Kefir lists 5 g per 2/3 cup. The serving sizes differ, so check both.
Guides
Can Yuka Scan Supplements? It Lists Them as Not RatedYuka's help center lists dietary, nutritional and protein supplements among products it does not rate, along with alcohol, pet food and cleaning products.
Comparisons
Is Daisy Healthier Than Breakstone's Sour Cream? 60 Cal EachDaisy lists one ingredient, cultured cream; Breakstone's lists cultured pasteurized cream and enzymes. Both have 60 calories and 3.5 g saturated fat per 2 tbsp.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy