Comparisons · November 20, 2026 · 7 min read
Which Has More Protein, Lifeway or Maple Hill Kefir?
Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10 g protein per 1 cup; Maple Hill Plain Kefir lists 5 g per 2/3 cup. The serving sizes differ, so check both.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 20, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10g of protein and 10g of total sugars per 1 cup (240 mL) on its printed panel, while Maple Hill Creamery Organic Plain Kefir lists 5g of protein and 8g of total sugars per 2/3 cup (170g). Because the two panels use different serving sizes, their numbers cannot be compared directly without adjustment, so this guide sets the facts side by side.
Key takeaways
- Lifeway lists 10g protein per 1 cup. Maple Hill lists 5g per 2/3 cup, which scales to 7.5g per 1 cup by arithmetic only.
- Lifeway lists 10g total sugars and 0g added sugars per 1 cup. Maple Hill lists 8g total sugars per 2/3 cup, which scales to 12g per 1 cup by arithmetic only, and its photographed panel has no added sugars line.
- FDA's consumer guidance advises making sure serving sizes match before comparing %DV, so the 1 cup vs 2/3 cup gap has to be handled first.
- Lifeway's ingredients include pectin, lactase enzyme, and vitamin D3. Maple Hill's ingredient text lists organic whole milk and live and active cultures.
- The brand page says Lifeway has 12 live and active cultures and 50 billion CFUs per serving. The sources give no culture count for Maple Hill.
Which has more protein, Lifeway or Maple Hill kefir?
Per the printed labels, Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10g of protein per 1 cup (240 mL), and Maple Hill Creamery Organic Plain Kefir lists 5g per 2/3 cup (170g). On the printed panels, Lifeway shows more protein per listed serving.
Lifeway's product page describes its product as having 10 grams of complete protein per serving. The Maple Hill figure comes from its Nutrition Facts panel as photographed on Open Food Facts and as listed by Jewel-Osco.
The serving sizes make the comparison less direct. Because 1 cup is 1.5 times 2/3 cup, the Maple Hill figure works out to 7.5g per 1 cup (1.5 x 5g). That is arithmetic, not a number printed on the Maple Hill label. FDA's label guide says to use %DV to compare food products and to make sure the serving size is the same first (How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label), so the printed 10g and 5g figures are not a like-for-like comparison.
How much sugar is in Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir vs Maple Hill Organic Plain Kefir?
Lifeway lists 10g total sugars and 0g added sugars per 1 cup, and the brand describes the product as having no added sugar. Maple Hill lists 8g total sugars per 2/3 cup and no added sugars line on its photographed panel.
Scaled to 1 cup by the same 1.5 x arithmetic, Maple Hill would be 12g of total sugars. That figure does not appear on the Maple Hill label. A total sugars number alone does not show how much sugar was added, which is why the added sugars line matters when comparing panels.
The Jewel-Osco listing does not show an added sugars line either. Whether the Maple Hill product contains added sugar is not disclosed in these sources, so this article does not state a figure. For a parallel example on another dairy label, see the Hood and Organic Valley eggnog sugar comparison.
Why do the serving sizes of 1 cup and 2/3 cup change the comparison?
The two panels use different serving sizes, so their per-serving numbers cannot be read side by side without adjustment. FDA's consumer guidance on the Nutrition Facts label advises making sure the serving size is the same before comparing %DV across food products (How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label).
Lifeway's panel is set at 1 cup (240 mL). Maple Hill's panel is set at 2/3 cup (170g), and the Jewel-Osco listing describes about 5 servings per 32 oz container. The number of servings per Lifeway container is not stated in these sources.
| Label fact | Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir | Maple Hill Creamery Organic Plain Kefir |
|---|---|---|
| Serving size on panel | 1 cup (240 mL) | 2/3 cup (170g) |
| Calories | 150 | 120 |
| Total fat | 8g | 7g |
| Protein | 10g | 5g |
| Total sugars | 10g | 8g |
| Added sugars | 0g | Not on photographed panel |
| Sodium | 125mg | 85mg |
| Calcium | 390mg (30% DV) | 200mg (15% DV) |
| Container size | 32 oz | 32 oz (about 5 servings per container) |
Calcium shows why the serving size matters. Lifeway's panel shows 30% DV at 1 cup, and Maple Hill's shows 15% DV at 2/3 cup. Those percentages refer to different amounts, so they should not be read as a direct ranking.
How do the calories, fat, and sodium compare on each panel?
Lifeway's panel lists 150 calories, 8g total fat, 5g saturated fat, and 125mg sodium per 1 cup. Maple Hill's panel lists 120 calories, 7g total fat, 4.5g saturated fat, and 85mg sodium per 2/3 cup.
These figures are shown at each panel's own serving size, so they should not be read as a direct ranking. Cholesterol is also listed on both panels: 30mg per 1 cup for Lifeway and 25mg per 2/3 cup for Maple Hill. The Jewel-Osco listing shows the Maple Hill cholesterol figure as 9% DV.
What do the ingredient lists show for Lifeway and Maple Hill kefir?
Lifeway's ingredient list reads pasteurized milk, nonfat milk, pectin, lactase enzyme, vitamin D3, and cultures (Lifeway product page). Maple Hill's photographed panel and Jewel-Osco listing read organic whole milk and live and active cultures.
The Lifeway list includes three additions beyond milk and cultures. The label does not state why pectin or lactase enzyme is included. Vitamin D3 is added, which is consistent with the 3.8mcg (20% DV) shown on the Lifeway panel. The Maple Hill ingredient text on Open Food Facts lists no vitamin D3.
Organic wording appears in Maple Hill's name and ingredient text. The Lifeway ingredient text provided for this product does not include the word organic, so shoppers looking for organic dairy should check the front and back of the package. For another example of organic wording on dairy labels, see the 4th & Heart and Organic Valley ghee comparison.
What do the cultures wording and probiotic claims say on each label?
The Lifeway brand page says the product has 12 live and active probiotic cultures and provides 50 billion CFUs of probiotics per serving (Lifeway product page).
Maple Hill's photographed panel and Jewel-Osco listing say Live & Active Cultures, and the Maple Hill product page describes its plain kefir as 'full of healthy live and active probiotics' and 'cultivated with 100% grass-fed organic dairy.' Neither source gives a culture count or CFU figure for Maple Hill, so none is stated here.
Brand wording is not the same as an independent test result. The sources do not name Lifeway's 12 cultures.
Do the two kefirs differ on lactose, gluten, and allergen labeling?
Both labels declare milk as an allergen. The Lifeway brand page says its product is lactose-free and gluten-free, and Maple Hill's photographed panel carries 'GLUTEN FREE' side text. Lactose-free wording for Maple Hill is not disclosed in these sources.
Lifeway's allergen statement reads 'Contains: Milk,' and Maple Hill's reads 'Contains milk.' Anyone with a milk allergy should read the full label on the package they buy.
The gluten side text on the Maple Hill bottle photo does not appear in the Jewel-Osco listing text, so readers with gluten concerns should confirm the wording on their own bottle.
What is not disclosed in the sources for these two kefirs?
The sources do not give Maple Hill's probiotic strain names, a Maple Hill culture count, a Maple Hill added sugars figure, or any lactose-free claim for Maple Hill. They also do not name Lifeway's 12 cultures.
These are the gaps that remain for this comparison:
- Grams of protein per 1 cup printed on any Maple Hill label (only the arithmetic above exists)
- Any FODMAP or Certified Humane claim for Maple Hill
- Price per bottle or per serving for either product
How can you spot these claims on a kefir label yourself?
Start with the serving size line, then match amounts before you compare protein, sugar, or %DV. Use this checklist on any kefir or yogurt label:
- Find the serving size in cups, mL, or grams, and note the servings per container.
- Scale both panels to the same amount before comparing grams or %DV, as FDA guidance advises.
- Look for an Added Sugars line. If the panel has none, the panel does not show added sugars.
- Read the ingredient list for additions such as pectin, enzymes, or vitamins.
- Compare brand claims, such as culture counts, with what the panel and ingredient list actually print.
- Check the allergen statement, such as 'Contains: Milk,' and any free-from wording on the package.
Common questions
- Which kefir has the most protein?
- On the printed panels, Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir has more protein, with 10g per 1 cup (240 mL) versus 5g per 2/3 cup (170g) for Maple Hill Creamery Organic Plain Kefir. Scaling Maple Hill to 1 cup gives 7.5g by arithmetic, which is not printed on its label.
- Which kefir has the least sugar?
- Per 1 cup, Lifeway's panel lists 10g of total sugars. Scaling Maple Hill's 8g per 2/3 cup gives 12g per 1 cup by arithmetic, so Lifeway shows fewer total sugars per cup on these figures. Maple Hill's photographed panel has no Added Sugars line, so no added sugars figure is stated here.
- What is the healthiest kefir?
- The sources do not establish which kefir is healthier, and this article does not rank them. The label facts above allow a side-by-side reading at each panel's printed serving size.
- Does Lifeway kefir have added sugar?
- Lifeway's Nutrition Facts panel lists 0g of added sugars per 1 cup, and the brand says the product has no added sugar. The panel lists 10g of total sugars per 1 cup.
- How much sugar is in Lifeway kefir?
- Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10g of total sugars per 1 cup (240 mL) on its Nutrition Facts panel, with 0g of added sugars.
- Does Lifeway kefir have protein?
- Yes, Lifeway Whole Milk Plain Kefir lists 10g of protein per 1 cup (240 mL) on its panel, and the brand describes it as 10 grams of complete protein per serving.
Sources
- Whole Milk Plain Kefir - Lifeway Kefir (lifewaykefir.com)
- Grass Fed Kefir - Maple Hill (maplehill.com)
- Maple Hill Creamery Kefir Grsfed Plain Org - 32 Oz (jewelosco.com)
- Maple Hill Creamery Organic Plain Kefir, UPC 0855088005337 (world.openfoodfacts.org)
- How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)
In this series
Guide
Is 4th & Heart Ghee Organic? vs Organic Valley GheeGuide
Is Daisy Healthier Than Breakstone's Sour Cream? 60 Cal EachGuide
Which Has More Sodium, Cooked Perfect or Farm Rich?Guide
Is Del Monte Healthier Than Green Giant? Both 380mg SodiumGuide
How Does the Bobby Approved App Work? 10 Ingredient RulesGuide
Do Canned Yams Have Added Sugar? Bruce's, Princella: 4g
Related guides
Comparisons
Is 4th & Heart Ghee Organic? vs Organic Valley Ghee4th & Heart says it has no organic offering and sources grass-fed butter; Organic Valley ghee is USDA Organic. Ingredient lists and per-serving fat compared.
Comparisons
Do Canned Yams Have Added Sugar? Bruce's, Princella: 4gBruce's and Princella cut sweet potatoes in syrup both list 4g added sugars per 2/3 cup and 120 calories. Bruce's page lists sugar, not corn syrup.
Comparisons
Is Martinelli's Alcoholic? Martinelli's vs Welch's CiderMartinelli's says its cider contains no water, alcohol or sweeteners; Welch's 100% Cider Sparkling is apple juice from concentrate, labeled non alcoholic.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy