Aurascan

Comparisons · November 12, 2026 · 8 min read

Are Annie's Cinnamon Rolls Healthier Than Pillsbury?

Per roll with icing: Annie's has 330 calories, 750 mg sodium, 24 g added sugar; Pillsbury Grands has 320 calories, 540 mg sodium, 22 g added sugar.

By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 12, 2026

Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Illustration of two spiral cinnamon rolls side by side, one with glossy icing drizzle

This comparison does not pick a winner: per roll with icing, Annie's is higher in sodium and added sugar, while the Pillsbury label lists high fructose corn syrup, TBHQ and milk (modified whey).

Key takeaways

  • Per roll with icing, Annie's has 330 calories, 750 mg sodium (33% DV) and 24 g added sugar (48% DV). Pillsbury has 320 calories, 540 mg sodium (24% DV) and 22 g added sugar (43% DV).
  • The Pillsbury label lists high fructose corn syrup, TBHQ, potassium sorbate, polysorbate 60 and milk (modified whey). The Annie's label states no high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors and does not list TBHQ.
  • Annie's roll has 2 g fiber (5% DV) and 0.4 mg iron (2% DV). Pillsbury has 1 g fiber (4% DV), 1.8 mg iron (8% DV) and 240 mg potassium (6% DV).
  • The labels cannot show a health outcome for one roll.

At a glance, per roll with icing (both cans make five rolls):

Per roll with icingAnnie's Organic Cinnamon RollsPillsbury Grands! Cinnamon Rolls
Calories330320
Sodium750 mg (33% DV)540 mg (24% DV)
Added sugar24 g (48% DV)22 g (43% DV)
Saturated fat4.5 g (23% DV)4 g (20% DV)
Fiber2 g (5% DV)1 g (4% DV)
Iron0.4 mg (2% DV)1.8 mg (8% DV)
Potassium0 mg240 mg (6% DV)

Calories

Per roll with icing, Annie's Organic Cinnamon Rolls list 330 calories and Pillsbury Grands! Cinnamon Rolls with Original Icing list 320, a difference of 10 calories. Both brands list one roll with icing as the serving size, with five servings per container.

Annie's lists 11 g total fat (14% DV) and 4.5 g saturated fat (23% DV) per roll. Pillsbury lists 9 g total fat (11% DV) and 4 g saturated fat (20% DV). Both labels show 0 g trans fat and 0 mg cholesterol. Total carbohydrate is 53 g (19% DV) for Annie's and 54 g (20% DV) for Pillsbury. Both show 5 g protein per roll.

Are Annie's cinnamon rolls healthier than Pillsbury?

The two labels do not declare either roll healthier, and this article does not rank them. Per roll with icing, Annie's lists 330 calories, 11 g total fat (14% DV) and 4.5 g saturated fat (23% DV), while Pillsbury lists 320 calories, 9 g total fat (11% DV) and 4 g saturated fat (20% DV). How these numbers fit a person's needs depends on the rest of their diet.

Are Annie's cinnamon rolls healthy?

Per roll with icing, Annie's lists 330 calories, 750 mg sodium (33% DV) and 24 g added sugar (48% DV). The label facts alone cannot answer whether any food is healthy for a given person. The brand pages do not disclose the gram weight of one roll or the numbers for a roll without icing, so these figures describe only the rolls with icing.

Are Pillsbury cinnamon rolls bad for you?

The label does not classify Pillsbury Grands! as good or bad; per roll with icing it lists 320 calories, 540 mg sodium (24% DV) and 22 g added sugar (43% DV). Those values describe one roll only, and the brand page does not cover other Pillsbury cinnamon roll varieties.

Sodium

750 mg vs 540 mg, 210 mg more per roll: Annie's roll has more sodium, at 750 mg (33% DV) per roll with icing, while Pillsbury lists 540 mg (24% DV).

The FDA Daily Value for sodium is less than 2,300 mg per day, according to FDA's Sodium in Your Diet page. FDA considers 5% DV or less per serving low in sodium and 20% DV or more high. By that threshold, both rolls fall in the high range, since each is at 20% DV or above. Each figure is the amount listed for one roll with icing, so the difference grows with the number of rolls eaten. For a comparison of sodium in another packaged mix, see Which Has More Sodium, Old El Paso or McCormick Taco Mix?

Added sugar

Annie's roll lists 24 g added sugar (48% DV) and Pillsbury lists 22 g (43% DV), per roll with icing. The FDA Daily Value for added sugars is 50 grams per day based on a 2,000 calorie daily diet, and 20% DV or more is considered a high source of added sugars, per FDA's added sugars label page.

The Nutrition Facts panel shows total sugars first and then an indented "Incl. Added Sugars" line. Annie's lists 24 g total sugars, which matches its 24 g added sugars. Pillsbury lists 23 g total sugars, of which 22 g are added. Total sugars includes sugars that occur naturally in ingredients, so the added sugars line is the figure to compare when looking at sweeteners.

The ingredient lists show where the sugar comes from. Annie's lists organic cane sugar and organic invert syrup. Pillsbury lists sugar, dextrose, brown sugar, molasses, corn syrup, corn syrup solids and high fructose corn syrup. For another label comparison centered on sugar, see What's the Difference Between Justin's and MaraNatha? Sugar.

Additives

The Pillsbury label lists high fructose corn syrup, TBHQ and potassium sorbate, and the Annie's label does not list any of these. Each additive question is answered below using label facts only.

Does Pillsbury Grands! contain high fructose corn syrup, and does Annie's?

Pillsbury Grands! lists high fructose corn syrup in the part of its ingredient statement marked "Contains 2% or less of." The Annie's label does not list it, and the Annie's brand page states "No artificial flavors, synthetic colors or high fructose corn syrup."

What is TBHQ in Pillsbury Grands! Cinnamon Rolls, and is it on Annie's label?

TBHQ appears only on the Pillsbury label, where it is listed inside the vegetable shortening sub-ingredients as one of the preservatives. The Annie's ingredient list does not include TBHQ and does not name a preservative by that name.

The amount of TBHQ per roll is not disclosed on the Pillsbury brand page, and this article makes no health claim about it.

The Pillsbury label also lists potassium sorbate as a preservative, which the Annie's list does not show.

Which ingredients differ between the two cans?

The two ingredient lists differ across nearly every category. Here is how the labels compare:

  • Flour: Annie's uses organic wheat flour. Pillsbury uses enriched flour bleached, with niacin, ferrous sulfate, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin and folic acid added.
  • Fats: Annie's lists organic palm oil and organic expeller-pressed sunflower oil. Pillsbury lists palm and/or soybean oil plus vegetable shortening made from soybean oil, hydrogenated palm oil and fractionated palm oil.
  • Starches and emulsifiers: Annie's lists organic tapioca starch, xanthan gum, organic guar gum and organic locust bean gum. Pillsbury lists corn starch, sodium stearoyl lactylate, monoglycerides, sodium alginate and polysorbate 60.
  • Preservatives: Pillsbury lists TBHQ and potassium sorbate. The Annie's list does not name a preservative.
  • Color and flavor: Pillsbury lists annatto extract, caramel color, beta carotene and "Natural and Artificial Flavor." Annie's lists organic natural flavor and organic cinnamon, and its brand page states no synthetic colors or artificial flavors.
  • Leavening and other ingredients: Pillsbury lists dough conditioner (L-cysteine hydrochloride), vital wheat gluten and potassium chloride. Its baking powder includes sodium aluminum phosphate, which the Annie's baking powder does not list.

For another label comparison built around fats, see Does Jiffy Cornbread Have Lard? Krusteaz Uses Soybean Oil.

Allergens

The Pillsbury label declares wheat and milk, while the Annie's label declares only wheat.

The Pillsbury allergen line reads "CONTAINS WHEAT AND MILK INGREDIENTS." The Annie's label reads "Contains wheat ingredients" and does not name milk.

Does Annie's cinnamon rolls have dairy?

The Annie's label does not list a milk ingredient and declares only wheat, for the roll with icing. Whether the icing is made on dairy-free equipment is not disclosed on the brand page, and the label does not address cross-contact.

Do Pillsbury cinnamon rolls have dairy?

Yes, the Pillsbury label states "CONTAINS WHEAT AND MILK INGREDIENTS" and lists modified whey, a milk-derived ingredient, within its 2% or less group.

Micronutrients

Annie's lists 2 g dietary fiber (5% DV) per roll, and Pillsbury lists 1 g (4% DV). Pillsbury lists 1.8 mg iron (8% DV) per roll, compared with 0.4 mg (2% DV) for Annie's. Pillsbury lists 240 mg potassium (6% DV), while Annie's lists 0 mg.

Both labels show 0 mcg vitamin D and 0 mg calcium per roll. These values describe one roll with icing, and the brand pages do not show nutrient values for a roll without icing.

Limits of the label evidence

The label facts in this article cannot show whether either roll suits a specific diet, and they do not measure how any individual responds to a roll.

How can a shopper spot these ingredients and claims on any cinnamon roll label?

A shopper can compare most of the differences above by reading the Nutrition Facts panel and the ingredient statement together. Start with the serving size, then check the % DV column against FDA reference values.

  • Check the serving size and servings per container. Both cans here list one roll with icing and five servings.
  • Compare sodium with the FDA Daily Value of less than 2,300 mg per day.
  • Read the indented "Incl. Added Sugars" line under total sugars, then compare it with the 50 g Daily Value.
  • Read ingredients in order, and check parenthetical sub-ingredients, such as the vegetable shortening breakdown on the Pillsbury label.
  • Look for the "Contains 2% or less of" group, which can include several additives and sweeteners.
  • Read the allergen line, such as "CONTAINS WHEAT AND MILK INGREDIENTS."
  • Treat claims such as "no high fructose corn syrup" as statements to verify against the ingredient list.

These label facts cannot show how any individual responds to either roll. The brand pages do not disclose the gram weight of one roll, a roll without icing, or whether the icing is made on dairy-free equipment.

Try Aurascan

See what is really in the food you buy.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Common questions

Are Annie's cinnamon rolls healthier than Pillsbury?
The labels do not declare either roll healthier. Per roll with icing, Annie's lists 330 calories and 750 mg sodium (33% DV), while Pillsbury lists 320 calories and 540 mg sodium (24% DV).
Are Annie's cinnamon rolls healthy?
The label facts alone cannot answer whether a food is healthy for a given person. Per roll with icing, Annie's lists 330 calories, 750 mg sodium and 24 g added sugar (48% DV).
Are Pillsbury cinnamon rolls bad for you?
The label does not classify Pillsbury Grands! as good or bad. Per roll with icing, it lists 320 calories, 540 mg sodium (24% DV) and 22 g added sugar (43% DV).
Does Annie's cinnamon rolls have dairy?
Annie's label does not list a milk ingredient or a milk allergen statement for the roll with icing, and it declares only wheat. Whether the icing is made on dairy-free equipment is not disclosed.
Do Pillsbury cinnamon rolls have dairy?
Yes, the Pillsbury label states CONTAINS WHEAT AND MILK INGREDIENTS and lists modified whey, a milk-derived ingredient.
Does Pillsbury Grands! have high fructose corn syrup?
Yes, Pillsbury Grands! Cinnamon Rolls with Original Icing lists high fructose corn syrup in its 2% or less group. The Annie's label does not list it and states no high fructose corn syrup.

Sources

  1. Annie's Organic Cinnamon Rolls (annies.com)
  2. Pillsbury Grands! Original Cinnamon Rolls with Icing (pillsbury.com)
  3. Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)
  4. Sodium in Your Diet (fda.gov)

In this series

Related guides

Try it on your own groceries

Scan your next label with Aurascan

Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

See a sample result

Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest

An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.

We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy