Aurascan

Comparisons · November 12, 2026 · 8 min read

SunButter vs Wowbutter: Soy, Sugar and Sodium Compared

Per 2 Tbsp (32 g), both have 200 calories and 7 g protein. SunButter Creamy: 130 mg sodium, 3 g added sugar. Wowbutter: 100 mg, 2 g, and it contains soy.

By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 12, 2026

Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Illustration of two open glass jars of creamy spread with a butter knife beside each

Per 2 Tbsp (32 g), SunButter Creamy and Wowbutter Creamy both list 200 calories and 7 g protein, so those numbers do not separate them. The labels differ on the base ingredient, the allergen statement, and smaller gaps in added sugar, sodium, and saturated fat. Wowbutter's US label names soy as its one major allergen, while SunButter is made from sunflower seeds and claims to be free from the top 9 allergens.

Key takeaways

  • Both products list a 2 Tbsp (32 g) serving, 200 calories, and 7 g protein.
  • Wowbutter's own allergen chart marks soya as present in the product, on the same line, and in the same plant.
  • SunButter Creamy lists roasted sunflower seeds, sugar, mono and diglycerides, and salt, and carries a 'Nut-Free' and 'FREE FROM TOP 9 ALLERGENS' claim.
  • SunButter has 3 g added sugar and 130 mg sodium per 2 Tbsp. Wowbutter has 2 g added sugar and 100 mg sodium per 2 Tbsp.

What are the main differences between SunButter Creamy and Wowbutter Creamy per 2 Tbsp?

The two spreads match on calories and protein but differ on their base ingredient, allergen statements, and several small nutrient lines. The table below places the Nutrition Facts values for each product side by side.

Label item (per 2 Tbsp, 32 g)SunButter CreamyWowbutter Creamy (US label)
Base ingredientRoasted sunflower seedsWhole toasted soy
Calories200200
Total fat16 g (21% DV)15 g (19% DV)
Saturated fat2 g (10% DV)3 g (15% DV)
Sodium130 mg (6% DV)100 mg (4% DV)
Total carbohydrate7 g (3% DV)8 g (3% DV)
Dietary fiber3 g (10% DV)3 g (11% DV)
Total sugars4 g3 g
Added sugars3 g (6% DV)2 g (4% DV)
Protein7 g (9% DV)7 g (no DV listed)
Calcium2% DV40 mg (4% DV)
Iron8% DV1 mg (6% DV)
Potassium4% DV300 mg (8% DV)
Allergen statementClaims Nut-Free and free from top 9 allergensStates soy is its only major allergen

The panels are the primary reference. Check the jar you are holding, because label formulations can change.

Which allergens does SunButter Creamy list, and is it free from the top 9 allergens?

SunButter Creamy lists roasted sunflower seeds as its base, and its product page states 'FREE FROM TOP 9 ALLERGENS' and 'Nut-Free'. The page does not include a separate shared-line or facility statement, so that detail was not disclosed in the sources.

The ingredient line reads 'Roasted sunflower seeds, Sugar, Mono & diglycerides, Salt.' Sunflower seed is not on the FDA's list of major food allergens, which names milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame.

The brand also lists Non-GMO, gluten-free, and kosher certifications on its page. A certification is not the same as an allergen statement, so readers should read both.

Which allergens does Wowbutter Creamy list, and why does soy matter on its label?

Wowbutter Creamy's US label makes soy its one major allergen, and its allergen chart lists soya as present in the product, on the same line, and in the same plant. Soy is the main allergen to check on this jar.

The brand's US nutrition page states: 'WOWBUTTER is free of all major allergens EXCEPT SOY. It is produced in a dedicated peanut free and tree nut free facility.' Its allergen chart marks peanuts, tree nuts, sesame, milk, and eggs as NO in the product, on the same line, and in the same plant.

The chart is more detailed on grain allergens. Wheat is marked NO in the product and on the same line, but YES in the same manufacturing plant. Gluten is marked NO in the product but YES in the same plant. Readers who avoid wheat or gluten should weigh that plant-level note alongside the ingredient list. For a related label example, see Does Bumble Bee Tuna Have Soy? Yes; StarKist Says No for how soy appears on another packaged food.

How much added sugar is in SunButter Creamy vs Wowbutter Creamy per 2 Tbsp?

SunButter Creamy lists 3 g added sugars per 2 Tbsp (6% DV), while Wowbutter Creamy lists 2 g added sugars per 2 Tbsp (4% DV). The difference is 1 g per serving.

SunButter's Nutrition Facts panel shows 4 g total sugars, including the 3 g added sugars. Wowbutter's panel shows 3 g total sugars, including 2 g added. The brand's ingredient notes say its cane sugar adds '2g per 32g serving,' which matches the label. The SunButter ingredient list says only 'Sugar,' so the type of sugar was not disclosed in the sources.

If you compare added sugar across spreads, use the same serving size. A jar's total servings may differ from the 2 Tbsp basis, and the table above uses the per-serving figures only. For a comparison where two products list the same added sugar amount, see Oatly vs Silk Oat Milk: Why Both List 7 g Added Sugar.

How much sodium is in SunButter Creamy vs Wowbutter Creamy per 2 Tbsp?

SunButter Creamy lists 130 mg sodium per 2 Tbsp (6% DV), and Wowbutter Creamy lists 100 mg (4% DV). SunButter has 30 mg more sodium per serving.

Both ingredient lists end with salt, and the panels show the difference only in the sodium line. Readers managing sodium for medical reasons should follow guidance from their own clinician rather than a label comparison.

How much protein and fat do SunButter Creamy and Wowbutter Creamy provide per 2 Tbsp?

Both Creamy spreads list 7 g protein per 2 Tbsp (32 g), and SunButter lists 16 g total fat while Wowbutter lists 15 g. The fat gap is 1 g.

SunButter's page says '7g protein per serving,' and its panel lists the protein at 9% DV. Wowbutter's panel lists 7 g without a daily value. Saturated fat runs the other way: SunButter lists 2 g (10% DV) and Wowbutter lists 3 g (15% DV). Trans fat is 0 g on both panels, and cholesterol is 0 mg on both.

The labels do not provide protein quality scores, so comparisons of protein quality were not disclosed in the sources.

What do the ingredient lists show about palm oil, mono and diglycerides, and cane sugar?

Wowbutter lists palm oil and cane sugar, while SunButter lists mono and diglycerides and sugar. These are the ingredient lines that differ most after the base ingredient.

Wowbutter's ingredient line includes 'Palm Oil (Sustainable, 4% or less added to prevent oil separation).' The brand's ingredient notes describe a small amount of RSPO certified palm oil added for the same purpose. SunButter's ingredient list instead includes 'Mono & diglycerides,' which are emulsifiers, and the sources do not state how SunButter prevents oil separation. Both ingredient lists include a sugar and salt.

When reading these lines, match the ingredient names to the panel. Oil and emulsifier lines are often placed after the base ingredient, so the order on the jar helps show relative amounts.

Why does the FDA allergen list matter when comparing sunflower and soy spreads?

The FDA's list of major food allergens includes soybeans but not sunflower seed, which is why the two spreads carry different allergen statements. The FDA page names milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame as the major food allergens.

Sesame became the ninth major food allergen effective January 1, 2023, and the FDA's food allergies page is the regulatory reference for the list. Because sunflower seed is not on the list, a 'free from top 9' claim on SunButter does not mean the product is free of every seed, and Wowbutter's soy status is a regulated allergen rather than an optional note.

The list describes what regulators classify as major, not the full range of allergies people may have. A person's reaction depends on their own sensitivity, and this article cannot predict that.

Who should read these labels most carefully, and what is not disclosed in the sources?

People with soy allergy, sunflower or seed allergy, or wheat and gluten sensitivity should read these labels most closely. Parents packing lunches and shoppers buying for others with food allergies also benefit from checking the full allergen statement each time.

Several details were not disclosed in the sources. SunButter's facility or shared-line statement is not on the opened product page. Jar size in ounces for either product was not disclosed. Vitamin E and magnesium amounts are not on either label panel. Whether a given school accepts either spread was not disclosed. The sources also do not include Wowbutter Crunchy or SunButter Natural, No Sugar Added, or Organic numbers, so this comparison covers only the Creamy versions.

The evidence cannot establish how any individual will react to either spread, whether cross-contact occurs at levels that matter to a given person, or how the products compare for groups not covered by the label data. Readers with soy or sunflower allergies should check the current package label and consult a clinician.

How do you check the allergen and sugar lines on a SunButter or Wowbutter jar?

Start with the allergen statement, then the ingredient list, then the Nutrition Facts panel. Each step answers a different question, and the order keeps the allergen check from being skipped.

  • Find the allergen statement and check whether soy or sunflower appears in the ingredient list.
  • Look for 'contains' or 'may contain' wording, and compare it with any facility statement on the package.
  • Confirm the serving size, then read added sugars and sodium on the same basis.
  • Compare the ingredient order and any emulsifier or oil lines against the panel.
  • Keep the current jar on hand, since labels and retail listings can differ from the brand pages cited here.

For a second example of reading a packaged label for a gluten question, see Does Kikkoman Have Gluten? It Lists Wheat; La Choy Doesn't.

Try Aurascan

See what is really in the food you buy.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Common questions

Is Wowbutter or SunButter better?
The labels do not establish one as better, because they differ on allergens, added sugar, sodium, and saturated fat in different directions. Per 2 Tbsp, Wowbutter lists 2 g added sugar and 100 mg sodium, while SunButter lists 3 g added sugar and 130 mg sodium.
Is SunButter healthier than peanut butter?
This article does not compare SunButter with peanut butter, because the sources cover only the two Creamy spreads. Compare the Nutrition Facts panel and allergen statement on the peanut butter you are considering.
Does Wowbutter have soy?
Yes. Wowbutter Creamy lists whole toasted soy and pressed soy oil as ingredients, and its allergen chart marks soya as present in the product, on the same line, and in the same plant.
Is Wowbutter allowed in schools?
Whether a given school accepts Wowbutter was not disclosed in the sources. Check the school's own food and allergy policy before packing or serving it.
Is SunButter nut free?
The SunButter Creamy product page says 'Nut-Free,' and its ingredient list shows roasted sunflower seeds. The page does not include a shared-line or facility statement, so that detail was not disclosed.
Does Wowbutter have peanuts?
Its allergen chart marks peanuts as NO in the product, NO on the same line, and NO in the same plant. The brand also states the product is produced in a dedicated peanut free and tree nut free facility.

Sources

  1. Food Allergies (fda.gov)
  2. Creamy SunButter Sunflower Seed Butter (sunbutter.com)
  3. WOWBUTTER US Nutrition Facts (wowbutter.com)
  4. WOWBUTTER Allergy Information (US) (wowbutter.com)
  5. WOWBUTTER Better Than PB (US) ingredient notes (wowbutter.com)

In this series

Related guides

Try it on your own groceries

Scan your next label with Aurascan

Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

See a sample result

Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest

An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.

We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy