Comparisons · November 13, 2026 · 9 min read
Is MadeGood Healthier Than Z Bar? 6 g vs 9 g Added Sugar
MadeGood Chocolate Chip bars list 100 calories and 6 g added sugar per 24 g bar; Zbar lists 140 calories and 9 g per 36 g bar. Full labels side by side.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 13, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

This side-by-side compares the label facts printed on the brand pages for the MadeGood Chocolate Chip Granola Bar and the Zbar Chocolate Chip bar (formerly CLIF Kid Zbar). The two bars are different sizes, 24 g and 36 g, so every figure below is per bar unless the arithmetic is shown.
In short: Per bar, MadeGood lists 100 calories, 6 g added sugar, 5 mg sodium and 1 g fiber in a 24 g bar, while Zbar lists 140 calories, 9 g added sugar, 105 mg sodium and 2 g fiber in a 36 g bar. The labels give those numbers; they do not say which bar is healthier, and this article does not pick one.
Key takeaways
- Per bar, MadeGood lists 6 g added sugar (12% DV) and 5 mg sodium, while Zbar lists 9 g added sugar (17% DV) and 105 mg sodium, based on the brand pages cited here.
- Fiber is 1 g per 24 g MadeGood bar and 2 g per 36 g Zbar bar, so the printed panels show Zbar with double the fiber in a bar that is 50% heavier.
- MadeGood's brand page prints two ingredient lists with a different order for several items. The brand page does not say which of its two lists matches current packaging, so the package you hold is the one to read.
- Zbar's allergen statement reads 'Contains soy. May contain peanuts, tree nuts, milk, sesame, and wheat.' MadeGood's brand page describes its bars as nut-free and uses dairy-free chocolate chips.
- By arithmetic from the label numbers, 6 g of 24 g and 9 g of 36 g are both 25% added sugar by weight, so the Zbar's higher gram figure comes from the larger bar.
| Label item | MadeGood Chocolate Chip Granola Bar | Zbar Chocolate Chip |
|---|---|---|
| Serving size | 1 bar (24 g) | 1 bar (36 g) |
| Calories | 100 | 140 |
| Total fat | 3 g (4% DV) | 5 g (6% DV) |
| Saturated fat | 1 g (5% DV) | 1 g (6% DV) |
| Trans fat | 0 g | 0 g |
| Cholesterol | 0 mg | 0 mg |
| Total sugars | 6 g | 10 g |
| Added sugars | 6 g (12% DV) | 9 g (17% DV) |
| Sodium | 5 mg (0% DV) | 105 mg (5% DV) |
| Total carbohydrate | 17 g (6% DV) | 24 g (9% DV) |
| Dietary fiber | 1 g (4% DV) | 2 g (10% DV) |
| Protein | 2 g | 2 g |
| Second ingredient | Agave syrup | Tapioca syrup |
| Allergen statement | Brand page says nut-free; the printed list names no soy, milk, egg, wheat or nut ingredient | Contains soy. May contain peanuts, tree nuts, milk, sesame, and wheat. |
Which Granola Bar Has More Added Sugar: MadeGood or Zbar?
The Zbar has more added sugar per 1 bar: 9 g (17% DV) compared with 6 g (12% DV) for the MadeGood bar, each per 1 serving. The Zbar also lists 10 g total sugars against 6 g for MadeGood.
The bars differ in weight, so the per-gram picture is different. 6 g of added sugar in a 24 g bar is 25% by weight, and 9 g in a 36 g bar is also 25% by weight. The 50% larger serving of the Zbar accounts for its higher gram figure.
The FDA's page Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label states that the Daily Value for added sugars is 50 grams per day based on a 2,000 calorie daily diet. It classes 5% DV or less as a low source and 20% DV or more as a high source of added sugars, so both bars, at 12% and 17% DV, sit between low and high. The FDA also says added sugars include sugars from syrups and honey. The MadeGood ingredient lists name agave syrup, cane sugar, brown rice syrup and invert cane syrup. The Zbar ingredient list names tapioca syrup, cane sugar and cane syrup. Neither panel gives grams for each ingredient, so the sugar total cannot be split by source.
How Many Calories Are in MadeGood and Zbar Chocolate Chip Bars?
One MadeGood bar lists 100 calories per 1 bar, and one Zbar lists 140 calories per 1 bar, each on the brand page's Nutrition Facts panel. Those figures apply to a 24 g MadeGood bar and a 36 g Zbar.
The fat and protein lines are close. MadeGood lists 3 g total fat (4% DV) and 1 g saturated fat (5% DV). Zbar lists 5 g total fat (6% DV) and 1 g saturated fat (6% DV). Both list 0 g trans fat, 0 mg cholesterol and 2 g protein.
Carbohydrate is 17 g (6% DV) for MadeGood and 24 g (9% DV) for Zbar. By calculation, dividing calories by weight gives about 4.2 calories per gram for MadeGood (100 divided by 24) and about 3.9 for Zbar (140 divided by 36). That gap is small, and the printed calorie figure is the reference point to use when you compare packages.
Which Bar Has More Sodium: MadeGood or Zbar Chocolate Chip?
The Zbar has 105 mg sodium (5% DV) per 1 bar, compared with 5 mg (0% DV) for the MadeGood bar. The difference is 100 mg per bar.
Both products name salt in their ingredient lists. The Zbar list includes SALT as a named ingredient. On MadeGood's brand page, one printed ingredient list includes 'Sea Salt' inside Brown Rice Crisps, and the other list includes 'Salt' at the end. Ingredient lists do not show how much salt each item contributes, so the panel figures are the reliable numbers.
How Much Fiber Is in MadeGood vs Zbar Chocolate Chip Bars?
The Zbar lists 2 g dietary fiber (10% DV) per 1 bar, and the MadeGood bar lists 1 g (4% DV) per 1 bar. Per bar, Zbar has double the fiber on the printed panels.
The Zbar brand page states that each bar has 12 grams of whole grains, and its oat blend includes rolled oats, oat flour and oat fiber. The MadeGood brand page lists its first ingredient as pure gluten free oats, marked organic.
The bars differ in weight here too. By arithmetic, 1 g of fiber in a 24 g bar is about 4.2% by weight (1 divided by 24), and 2 g in a 36 g bar is about 5.6% (2 divided by 36).
Why Does the Ingredient Order Differ Between MadeGood's Two Listings?
MadeGood's brand page prints two ingredient lists that differ in order. The first list appears with the nutrition panel, and the second appears under 'What's Inside'. In both, oats come first and agave syrup comes second, but several other items move. In the second list, sunflower oil and invert cane syrup switch places, Brown Rice Crisps moves later, the vegetable extract list names carrots and tomatoes in addition to the items in the first list, agar and natural flavor swap positions, and salt appears as the last item.
The brand page does not say which of its two lists matches the box currently on shelves. It states that product information and packaging may change and refers readers to the packaging on store shelves. The printed box is therefore the only reliable source for the ingredient order on any given package.
Zbar's brand page shows a single printed ingredient list. It begins with an oat blend, then lists tapioca syrup second, fig paste third, sunflower and/or soybean oil fourth, and cane sugar fifth, followed by cane syrup. Ingredient lists are generally arranged by weight, so the order is a rough guide to what dominates each product, not a measured amount. Neither brand page gives gram amounts for individual ingredients.
What Allergens Are in MadeGood and Zbar Chocolate Chip Bars?
The Zbar brand page carries the statement 'CONTAINS SOY. MAY CONTAIN PEANUTS, TREE NUTS, MILK, SESAME, AND WHEAT.' Soy appears in the ingredient list through soy lecithin and, depending on the oil used, sunflower and/or soybean oil, which is why the soy declaration applies.
MadeGood's brand page describes the bars as 'Nut-free', with 'gluten-free oats, dairy-free chocolate chips, and organic sweeteners'. Its printed ingredient lists name no soy, milk, egg, wheat or tree nut ingredient. Whether the bars are made in a dedicated allergen-free facility is not disclosed on the page, and a nut-free description on a web page is not a guarantee for any individual child or school.
The two pages present this differently: Zbar's carries a soy declaration and a 'may contain' list, while MadeGood's gives ingredient lists and a nut-free description. Neither page describes how much cross-contact occurs. Anyone with a food allergy should read the package they are holding and follow guidance from their own clinician.
How Do the Vitamin and Mineral Panels Compare Between the Two Bars?
MadeGood's panel lists vitamin D at 3.4 mcg (20% DV), vitamin E at 3 mg (20% DV) and thiamin at 0.3 mg (25% DV). Its brand page also lists vitamin C at 15% DV. The amount printed beside that vitamin C percentage does not carry a usable milligram figure, so only the 15% DV is quoted here.
Zbar's panel lists vitamin D at 0 mcg (0% DV), calcium at 15 mg (2% DV), iron at 1 mg (6% DV) and potassium at 92 mg (2% DV). Vitamin E is shown as 8% DV, phosphorus as 4% DV and magnesium as 6% DV. The panel gives only percentages for those last three, so their milligram amounts are not disclosed.
Minerals that appear on both panels are close on percentages. MadeGood lists calcium at 10 mg (0% DV), iron at 0.7 mg (4% DV) and potassium at 60 mg (2% DV). Vitamin content differs more than mineral content, and MadeGood's vitamin D and vitamin E lines are higher than Zbar's on the panels reviewed. Vitamin amounts on a snack bar do not show what a person's total intake would be, since diets include many other foods.
Where Can You Find Other Snack Comparisons in This Cluster?
The snack cluster includes side-by-side label comparisons for sodium, added sugar and oils in packaged snacks. For a kids' snack with a sugar question, see Do Gerber Puffs Have Added Sugar? Puffs vs Cheerios. For a sodium comparison among popular snack crackers, see Which Has More Sodium, Goldfish or Annie's Bunnies?.
To check any bar yourself, start with the serving size, then compare the added sugar grams and %DV, the sodium milligrams, the fiber, and the ingredient order on the package in your hand.
What These Labels Cannot Establish
The label facts here describe one serving of two specific products as printed on brand pages. They do not show how any individual child, adult or other eater responds to them. Health outcomes, glycemic effects, heavy metals and lab testing are not on either label and are not covered here, and prices are not compared. The Zbar Protein line is a different product that is not compared here. An older Zbar Chocolate Chip label with different figures and ingredients is still shown on another product-information site, so this article uses only the current brand product page and does not mix the two; if the box you hold prints different numbers, the box is the one to read. Whether either bar is appropriate for toddlers or infants is not addressed by these labels.
Common questions
- Are Z bars healthy for kids?
- The Zbar label does not make a health verdict, but its Chocolate Chip bar lists 140 calories, 9 g added sugar (17% DV), 105 mg sodium (5% DV) and 2 g fiber per 36 g bar. Whether that fits a particular child's diet is not something the label can settle, so a pediatrician or registered dietitian is the right person to ask.
- Are Z bars healthy for toddlers?
- The Nutrition Facts panel does not address toddlers, and no toddler-specific guidance appears on the labels in this comparison, so that question is not answered here. The panel values for one 36 g Zbar Chocolate Chip bar are 9 g added sugar and 105 mg sodium, and the Zbar label carries a soy declaration and a 'may contain' list for peanuts, tree nuts, milk, sesame and wheat.
- Are Clif Kid Z bars healthy?
- The brand page describes the Zbar Chocolate Chip bar as USDA certified organic, with 12 grams of whole grains per bar and no high-fructose corn syrup, artificial flavors, colors or preservatives. The label alone does not establish a health outcome, and the printed panel shows 140 calories, 9 g added sugar and 105 mg sodium per bar.
- Are Made Good granola minis healthy?
- The facts in this comparison cover the MadeGood Chocolate Chip Granola Bar at 24 g and 100 calories, not the granola mini format, so the mini bar's label values are not disclosed here. Readers can check the Nutrition Facts panel, ingredient order and allergen statement on the specific mini package they hold.
- Are Z bars actually healthy?
- The label facts show the Zbar Chocolate Chip bar at 140 calories, 9 g added sugar (17% DV), 105 mg sodium (5% DV) and 2 g fiber per 36 g bar, but they do not establish whether the bar is healthy for any individual. Health outcomes for this bar are not on the label and are not covered here, so the answer depends on the reader's needs and their own clinician's guidance.
- Which has more sugar, MadeGood or Zbar?
- The Zbar Chocolate Chip bar has more added sugar per bar, at 9 g (17% DV) per 36 g bar compared with 6 g (12% DV) per 24 g MadeGood bar. Both bars are 25% added sugar by weight when the label grams are divided by the bar weight, so the 50% larger Zbar serving accounts for the higher gram figure.
- Is MadeGood Chocolate Chip Granola Bar nut-free?
- The MadeGood brand page describes the bars as nut-free, and its printed ingredient lists name no tree nut or peanut ingredient. Whether the bars are made in a dedicated allergen-free facility is not disclosed on the page, so readers with a nut allergy should follow their own clinician's advice.
Sources
- MadeGood Chocolate Chip Granola Bars (madegoodfoods.com)
- Clif Kid Zbar Chocolate Chip (clifbar.com)
- Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)
In this series
Guide
Which Has More Sodium, Chex Mix or Gardetto's?Guide
Oreo vs Newman-O's: Only Oreo Lists HFCS, Artificial FlavorGuide
What Oil Is in Boulder Canyon vs Kettle Chips? AvocadoGuide
Does SkinnyPop Have Seed Oils? Yes; LesserEvil Uses CoconutGuide
Dole vs Del Monte Fruit Cups: Sugar, Gel and JuiceGuide
Which Has More Sugar, Tate's or Chips Ahoy? Tate's Does
Related guides
Comparisons
Which Has More Sugar, CTC or Golden Grahams? 12 g a CupCinnamon Toast Crunch and Golden Grahams each list 12 g added sugars per 1 cup. Only Cinnamon Toast Crunch lists BHT; Golden Grahams has more sodium.
Comparisons
Royal Dansk or Kjeldsens? Only One Lists Egg YolkPer 4 cookies (30 g) both tins list 150 calories and 8 g sugars; Kjeldsens adds currants and dried egg yolk, Royal Dansk lists eggs only as a may-contain.
Guides
Lowest-Sugar Kids' Cereal: 12 Brands Ranked by LabelOriginal Cheerios lists 2 g sugar per 1 1/2 cup; Apple Jacks lists 13 g per 1 1/3 cup. See where Froot Loops, Kix and 8 more land, by label.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy