Comparisons · November 13, 2026 · 7 min read
Wild Planet vs Season Sardines: Sodium, Protein, Omega-3
Per 85g, Wild Planet sardines in olive oil list 250mg sodium and 17g protein; Season's bone-in can lists 340mg and 22g. Species and origin differ too.
By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 13, 2026
Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Per 85g, the Wild Sardines In Extra Virgin Olive Oil page from Wild Planet lists 250mg sodium and 17g protein and names its omega-3 as EPA and DHA. The back panel linked from the Season Sardines page lists 340mg sodium and 22g protein and describes the can as Bone-In with Skin. Neither label establishes a healthier can.
This page places the printed label facts side by side.
Key takeaways
- Per 85g, Wild Planet lists 250mg sodium (11% DV) and Season lists 340mg (14% DV). Season's serving is 1/2 cup drained, and Wild Planet's serving is 3oz; both are 85g.
- Per 85g, Wild Planet lists 17g protein (34% DV) and Season lists 22g, with no %DV printed for Season's protein.
- Wild Planet states 974mg EPA and DHA omega-3, while Season states 1700mg omega-3 without naming EPA or DHA, so the two numbers are different measures and are not ranked here.
- Wild Planet names Sardinops sagax or Sardinops melanostictus from the North Pacific; Season names Sardina pilchardus from Atlantic Eastern/Central Waters, with product of Morocco.
- The Season back panel carries a California Proposition 65 cancer and reproductive harm warning. The Wild Planet product page does not state one, and the chemical behind the Season warning is not disclosed.
Which Sardine Can Has More Sodium: Wild Planet or Season?
Season has more sodium: 340mg (14% DV) per 85g, compared with 250mg (11% DV) for Wild Planet. The gap is 90mg per listed serving.
For context, the FDA's sodium guidance states that 'the Daily Value for sodium is less than 2,300 milligrams (mg) per day.' The Sodium in Your Diet page is the source for that wording.
Neither panel separates how much sodium comes from salt versus other sources. Wild Planet's ingredient list includes sea salt, and Season's list includes salt.
How Much Protein Is in Wild Planet vs Season Sardines Per 85g?
Season lists 22g of protein per 85g; Wild Planet lists 17g (34% DV). The Season panel prints no %DV for protein, so the percentage comparison runs in one direction only.
The 5g gap is a difference between two printed labels.
Is the Omega-3 in Wild Planet vs Season Sardines the Same Measure?
No. Wild Planet's Nutrition Facts state 974mg of EPA and DHA omega-3s per serving, while Season's panel highlights 1700mg omega-3 per serving, a total omega-3 figure that does not name EPA or DHA.
Because Season does not name its fatty acids, its figure cannot be matched line by line against the Wild Planet number. The EPA and DHA breakdown of Season's 1700mg is not disclosed, so the label does not show how much of that total is EPA and DHA. The two figures are different measures, so this page does not rank them or call either one higher.
Neither label shows a %DV for its omega-3 figure.
Which Species Is Wild Planet vs Season Sardines?
Wild Planet names Sardinops sagax or Sardinops melanostictus, while Season names Sardina pilchardus. The two labels also point to different fishing regions and countries of origin.
Wild Planet's page says its sardines are 'harvested in the North Pacific Ocean, working with well-managed fisheries in Japan' and 'Caught using single-species purse seine and drift net.' Those are the brand's own words. Season's panel lists the fishing region as Atlantic Ocean, Eastern/Central Waters and the product as a product of Morocco. These describe sourcing at different levels of detail.
Wild Planet's ingredient line gives two species names as options and does not say which one is in a given can.
Are Season Sardines Wild Caught?
Season's label does not state whether its sardines are wild caught; that is not disclosed. The panel names the species as Sardina pilchardus and the fishing region as Atlantic Ocean, Eastern/Central Waters, but it does not name a catch method.
Does Wild Planet Sardines Have Bones?
The Wild Planet product page does not state bone content for the can; that is not disclosed. The Wild Planet product page describes its fish as meaty and scale-free. Season's back panel, by contrast, calls its can Bone-In with Skin.
Are Wild Planet and Season Sardines Made With the Same Ingredients?
Both cans list sardines and organic extra virgin olive oil. Wild Planet's ingredient list also includes water, sea salt and aqueous natural smoke, while Season's list is limited to sardines (fish), organic extra virgin olive oil and salt.
The Wild Planet ingredient list reads: 'Sardines (Sardinops sagax or Sardinops melanostictus), organic extra virgin olive oil, water, sea salt, aqueous natural smoke'. The Season list reads: 'Sardines (Fish), Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Salt. CONTAINS: FISH.' Wild Planet's product page describes its sardines as having 'a lightly smoked flavor.'
The Season back panel image describes the can as Bone-In with Skin. The table below separates these label facts from the nutrient values.
| Label item | Wild Planet Wild Sardines | Season Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil (Bone-In with Skin) |
|---|---|---|
| Species | Sardinops sagax or Sardinops melanostictus | Sardina pilchardus |
| Fishing region or origin | North Pacific Ocean, Japan fisheries | Atlantic Ocean, Eastern/Central Waters; product of Morocco |
| Ingredients | Sardines, organic extra virgin olive oil, water, sea salt, aqueous natural smoke | Sardines (Fish), organic extra virgin olive oil, salt |
| Proposition 65 line | Not stated on product page | Cancer and reproductive harm warning |
Checking the ingredient list rather than the front of the package applies to other pantry staples too. See Do Mission Tortillas Have Lard? Mission vs Guerrero for another example.
Do Wild Planet and Season Sardines Carry the Same Warnings?
No. The Season back panel carries the line 'WARNING: Cancer and Reproductive Harm www.P65warnings.ca.gov', a California Proposition 65 warning, while the Wild Planet product page does not state an equivalent warning. Whether Wild Planet cans carry one is not disclosed on that page.
The Season warning line does not name the chemical involved, so the trigger is not disclosed and this page does not name one.
Neither brand's page gives mercury, arsenic or other heavy metal test results. The FDA's Advice About Eating Fish page lists sardine as a "Best Choice" and names sardines among fish that are lower in mercury. That is a general listing for sardines, not a test of these cans.
Can lining and BPA status are not disclosed for either can.
What Does the Side-by-Side Label Comparison Show for Calories and Fat?
Season lists 200 calories and 12g total fat per 85g, while Wild Planet lists 170 calories and 11g total fat. Both labels show 0g carbohydrate, 0g total sugars and 0g trans fat.
| Label item (per 85g unless noted) | Wild Planet Wild Sardines | Season Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil (Bone-In with Skin) |
|---|---|---|
| Serving size as printed | 3oz (85g), 1 serving per can | 1/2 cup drained (85g), 1 serving per container |
| Can size (not serving weight) | 4.4oz | 4.375 oz |
| Calories | 170 | 200 |
| Total fat | 11g (14% DV) | 12g (18% DV) |
| Saturated fat | 4g (20% DV) | 3g (15% DV) |
| Cholesterol | 40mg (13% DV) | 56mg (19% DV) |
| Sodium | 250mg (11% DV) | 340mg (14% DV) |
| Protein | 17g (34% DV) | 22g (no %DV printed) |
| Omega-3 | 974mg EPA and DHA | 1700mg omega-3 (EPA and DHA not named) |
| Calcium | 25% DV | 28% DV |
| Vitamin D | 15% DV | 15% DV |
| Iron | 10% DV | 8% DV |
| Potassium | 6% DV | 6% DV |
The calorie gap is 30 calories per 85g. Season has more cholesterol per serving (56mg vs 40mg) and less saturated fat (3g vs 4g). Iron is 10% DV on Wild Planet and 8% DV on Season, and vitamin D (15% DV) and potassium (6% DV) are the same on both panels.
How Should Shoppers Read Sardine Labels Using Serving Size and Fishing Region?
Compare cans by the gram weight of the serving first, then check the species and fishing region on the same panel. Both labels here use 85g, but they describe the serving in different words.
- Confirm the serving size in grams and whether the label says drained (Season does).
- Compare sodium in mg and %DV, using the FDA's Daily Value of less than 2,300mg per day.
- Check whether omega-3 is labeled as EPA and DHA or as a total figure.
- Read the species name and fishing region, which can differ between brands.
- Read the full ingredient list for added water, smoke or salt.
- Look for a Proposition 65 or other warning line.
The labels report no heavy metal or mercury test results for either brand, and the chemical behind the Season warning is not disclosed.
For other label comparisons, see Does Knorr Have MSG? Better Than Bouillon vs Knorr or Does PAM Have Silicone? PAM vs Chosen Avocado Oil Spray.
Try Aurascan
See what is really in the food you buy.
Common questions
- Is Wild Planet or Season sardines better?
- The labels do not name one can as better, because the two differ on sodium, protein, the omega-3 measure, species, origin, ingredients and warnings. Per 85g, Wild Planet lists 250mg sodium and 17g protein, while Season lists 340mg sodium and 22g protein.
- Are Season sardines wild caught?
- Season's label does not state whether its sardines are wild caught; that is not disclosed. The panel lists the species as Sardina pilchardus, the fishing region as Atlantic Ocean, Eastern/Central Waters, and the product as a product of Morocco.
- Are Wild Planet sardines boneless?
- The Wild Planet product page does not say whether the Wild Sardines can contains bones; that is not disclosed. The product page describes the fish as meaty and scale-free, while the Season can is labeled Bone-In with Skin.
- Are Season sardines healthy?
- The Season label lists 200 calories, 340mg sodium (14% DV), 22g protein and 1700mg omega-3 per 85g serving, but a nutrition label alone does not establish a health rating. The FDA's advice about eating fish lists sardine as a "Best Choice" and names sardines among fish that are lower in mercury.
- Does Wild Planet sardines have bones?
- The Wild Planet product page does not state bone content for the can; that is not disclosed. The Wild Planet product page describes the fish as meaty and scale-free, while the Season can is labeled Bone-In with Skin.
- Do Wild Planet and Season sardines have a Proposition 65 warning?
- The Season back panel carries a California Proposition 65 warning for cancer and reproductive harm, while the Wild Planet product page does not state an equivalent warning. The chemical that triggers the Season warning is not disclosed on the panel.
- What is the omega-3 difference between Wild Planet and Season sardines?
- Wild Planet states 974mg of EPA and DHA omega-3 per 85g serving, while Season states 1700mg omega-3 per serving without naming EPA or DHA. The two figures are different measures and are not ranked here, and the EPA and DHA breakdown of the Season number is not disclosed.
Sources
- Wild Sardines In Extra Virgin Olive Oil (wildplanetfoods.com)
- Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 4.375 oz can, back panel nutrition label (seasonproducts.com)
- Sardines product page (seasonproducts.com)
- Sodium in Your Diet (fda.gov)
- Advice About Eating Fish (fda.gov)
In this series
Guide
Is JUST Egg Healthier Than Egg Beaters? 60 vs 25 CaloriesGuide
Do Mission Tortillas Have Lard? Mission vs GuerreroGuide
Do Old El Paso Refried Beans Have Lard? Rosarita DoesGuide
Does PAM Have Silicone? PAM vs Chosen Avocado Oil SprayGuide
Can You Eat Pillsbury Cookie Dough Raw? Toll House ComparedGuide
Does Knorr Have MSG? Better Than Bouillon vs Knorr
Related guides
Comparisons
Mrs. Smith's vs Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie: CarrageenanMrs. Smith's filling lists carrageenan, guar gum and corn syrup; Marie Callender's crust lists hydrogenated soybean oil and sodium metabisulfite.
Comparisons
What's the Difference Between Eagle Brand and Carnation?Both list only milk and sugar and 130 calories per 2 Tbsp. Carnation shows 3.5 g fat and 45 mg sodium; Eagle Brand 3 g fat and 35 mg sodium.
Comparisons
Do Vitamin D3 Softgels Have Gelatin? Nature Made vs NOWBoth list gelatin. Nature Made: 'Soybean Oil, Gelatin, Glycerin.' NOW: olive oil, a 'bovine gelatin (BSE-free)' shell, safflower oil. Each has 25 mcg (1,000 IU), 125% DV.
Try it on your own groceries
Scan your next label with Aurascan
Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.
Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest
An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.
We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy