Aurascan

Comparisons · November 18, 2026 · 8 min read

Mrs. Smith's vs Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie: Carrageenan

Mrs. Smith's filling lists carrageenan, guar gum and corn syrup; Marie Callender's crust lists hydrogenated soybean oil and sodium metabisulfite.

By Chris Carrillo · Reviewed by Armin Rad, Co-Founder & CTO, Aurascan · November 18, 2026

Every article is checked against primary sources before publication. How we review

Illustration of two unbaked pumpkin pies in foil tins beside a whole pumpkin

TL;DR: Mrs. Smith's (as quoted on a Food Lion listing) and Marie Callender's both list milk, eggs and wheat, but only Mrs. Smith's filling lists carrageenan, guar gum and corn syrup, and only Marie Callender's crust lists hydrogenated soybean oil and sodium metabisulfite.

Per eighth of a pie, Marie Callender's shows 360 calories and 30 g of added sugars (60% DV), while the Food Lion listing for Mrs. Smith's shows 310 calories and 23 g (47% DV). The sections below set the label lines side by side.

Key takeaways

  • Both pies list milk, eggs and wheat and both carry no high fructose corn syrup and no artificial dyes claims.
  • Mrs. Smith's lists corn syrup, guar gum, carrageenan and butter. Marie Callender's lists hydrogenated soybean oil and sodium metabisulfite.
  • Per 1/8 pie (128 g), Marie Callender's shows 360 calories and 280 mg sodium. Mrs. Smith's, listed as 0.125 pie with no gram weight, shows 310 calories and 350 mg sodium. Saturated fat is 6 g on both.
  • Added sugars are 30 g (60% DV) for Marie Callender's and 23 g (47% DV) for Mrs. Smith's, both per eighth of a pie.
  • Marie Callender's reports 0 g trans fat per 1/8 pie. The label does not explain how its hydrogenated soybean oil relates to that figure.
  • Mrs. Smith's slice weight in grams is not disclosed, so its calories are not converted to a per-gram figure.

What are the ingredients in Mrs. Smith's vs Marie Callender's pumpkin pie?

Marie Callender's and Mrs. Smith's share milk, eggs and wheat but differ in their filling and crust ingredient lines.

Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie (frozen, 36 oz, UPC 612781101410) lists the following. Filling: pumpkin, sugar, water, nonfat dry milk, eggs, modified corn starch, spice, soybean oil and salt. Crust: enriched wheat flour, soybean oil, hydrogenated soybean oil, water, dextrose, salt and dough conditioner (sodium metabisulfite). The Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie product page links to the full Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie SmartLabel, whose directions say to bake at 350°F for 75 minutes, that the 'Pie must be cooked thoroughly to 165°F,' and to 'Refrigerate unused portion for up to 3 days after baking.'

Mrs. Smith's Original Flaky Crust Pumpkin Pie (frozen, 37 oz box) is quoted here from the Food Lion listing for Mrs. Smith's Original Flaky Crust Pumpkin Pie. Filling: pumpkin, sugar, milk, eggs, nonfat milk, corn syrup, modified food starch, spice, salt, guar gum, carrageenan and dextrose. Crust: wheat flour, palm oil, water, butter (cream, salt), soybean oil, salt, dextrose and yeast. The ingredient line on your own box is the one to check.

Label itemMarie Callender's (per 1/8 pie, 128 g)Mrs. Smith's (per 1/8 pie, listed as 0.125 pie; gram weight not disclosed)
Calories360310
Added sugars30 g (60% DV)23 g (47% DV)
Sodium280 mg350 mg
Saturated fat6 g (30% DV)6 g (29% DV)
Trans fat0 gNo gram figure on the Food Lion listing
Corn syrupNot listedListed
CarrageenanNot listedListed
Guar gumNot listedListed
Hydrogenated soybean oilListedNot listed
Sodium metabisulfiteListed (dough conditioner)Not listed
Milk, eggs, wheatContains all threeContains all three

Does Marie Callender's pumpkin pie have dairy?

Yes, the Marie Callender's label marks milk under Contains, from nonfat dry milk in the filling (per 1/8 pie, 128 g). Neither label makes a dairy-free or vegan claim.

Is Mrs. Smith's pumpkin pie gluten free?

The Food Lion listing does not describe Mrs. Smith's pie as gluten free, and it states 'Contains: milk, eggs and wheat.' Wheat flour is the first crust ingredient in that listing.

Which pumpkin pie has more added sugar per slice: Mrs. Smith's or Marie Callender's?

Marie Callender's has more added sugar per 1/8 pie (128 g), 30 g (60% DV), against 23 g (47% DV) per 0.125 pie for Mrs. Smith's. Total sugars are 37 g for Marie Callender's and 27 g for Mrs. Smith's on the panels used here.

The FDA sets the Daily Value for added sugars at 50 grams per day based on a 2,000 calorie diet, and it describes 20% DV or more as a high source of added sugars, according to the FDA page Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label. The Marie Callender's panel lists added sugars at 60% DV and the Mrs. Smith's listing at 47% DV.

The Mrs. Smith's listing gives its serving as 0.125 pie rather than a gram weight, so its sugar figure is per eighth of a pie, not per gram.

Why do these pies list corn syrup, carrageenan or hydrogenated soybean oil?

The labels name these ingredients but do not state why each manufacturer chose them. The ingredient lines show what is in each formula, and nothing more.

Mrs. Smith's filling lists corn syrup alongside sugar and dextrose. Marie Callender's filling does not list corn syrup. Both labels say 'No High Fructose Corn Syrup,' which is a narrower claim than having no corn syrup at all.

Carrageenan and guar gum appear only in Mrs. Smith's filling. Hydrogenated soybean oil appears only in Marie Callender's crust, and the label does not say how that fat blend is used.

Is carrageenan in Mrs. Smith's pumpkin pie safe, and what does the evidence say?

Mrs. Smith's filling lists carrageenan, and the Marie Callender's label does not. On the Food Lion listing it appears near the end of the filling line, after guar gum and before dextrose.

Neither the Food Lion listing nor the Marie Callender's SmartLabel makes a health statement about carrageenan, and this comparison does not make one either. The ingredient line shows that carrageenan is present in the Mrs. Smith's filling, and that is as far as the label facts go.

What does the evidence say about sodium metabisulfite in Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie?

Sodium metabisulfite appears in Marie Callender's crust. It is listed in parentheses after 'dough conditioner,' so it is not a separate line on the ingredient list.

The SmartLabel names sodium metabisulfite but makes no health statement about it, and this comparison does not make one either.

Mrs. Smith's listing does not show sodium metabisulfite, so this additive is a difference between the two labels only on the Marie Callender's side.

Is hydrogenated soybean oil in Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie a trans fat concern?

The Marie Callender's panel reports 0 g trans fat per 1/8 pie (128 g), and the label does not say whether its hydrogenated soybean oil is fully or partially hydrogenated. The crust ingredient reads 'Soybean Oil And Hydrogenated Soybean Oil.'

The label does not explain how the hydrogenated portion relates to the 0 g trans fat figure, so the panel line is the only trans fat information available here.

The Food Lion listing for Mrs. Smith's shows a trans fat line without a gram figure, so the two pies cannot be compared on that figure. For a separate comparison of a 0 g trans fat label on a shortening, see Does Crisco Have Trans Fat? 0 g Label vs Spectrum.

How do the two pies compare on sodium, saturated fat and calories?

Per 1/8 pie, Marie Callender's shows 360 calories, 280 mg sodium and 6 g saturated fat, while Mrs. Smith's (listed as 0.125 pie) shows 310 calories, 350 mg sodium and 6 g saturated fat.

The Marie Callender's serving is 128 g. The Mrs. Smith's gram weight is not disclosed on its listing, so calories cannot be converted to a per-gram comparison.

Other panel lines differ as well. Cholesterol is 35 mg vs 45 mg, total carbohydrate is 53 g vs 47 g, dietary fiber is 1 g vs 2 g, protein is 6 g vs 4 g, and potassium is 250 mg vs 180 mg. Marie Callender's also lists 150 mg calcium, which the Mrs. Smith's listing does not show. Readers with sodium or saturated fat targets can compare these lines against those targets. For a sodium comparison between two other packaged meals, see Is Rao's Lasagna Healthier Than Stouffer's? Sodium Compared.

How can you spot these additives on a frozen pumpkin pie label?

Read the Filling and Crust ingredient lines, the Contains statement and the Added Sugars line on the Nutrition Facts panel. Most of the differences in this comparison appear in those three places.

  • Corn syrup or modified corn starch in the filling line.
  • Carrageenan and guar gum in the filling line.
  • Hydrogenated oil in the crust line, including the words 'hydrogenated soybean oil.'
  • Sodium metabisulfite, which Marie Callender's shows in parentheses after 'dough conditioner.'
  • Front-of-box claims such as 'No High Fructose Corn Syrup' or 'No Artificial Dyes,' which do not mean the product lacks corn syrup or other additives.
  • Added Sugars and their %DV, read against the 50 g daily reference the FDA uses.

Both pies in this comparison carry the same no high fructose corn syrup and no artificial dyes claims and still list different additives, so the ingredient line is the more useful place to compare. For how a 'no artificial dyes' statement is read against an ingredient list on another product, see Does Centrum Have Artificial Dyes? Yellow 6 vs One A Day.

How can you compare other frozen pie labels yourself?

Compare any frozen pie using the same lines used here: serving size, ingredient list, allergen statement, added sugars and sodium. Start with the serving size, because calorie comparisons are unreliable when a slice weight is not shown.

Next, compare ingredient lines word by word. A product can carry a 'No High Fructose Corn Syrup' claim and still list corn syrup, as the Mrs. Smith's filling does, so the claim alone does not settle the question.

This comparison covers the Marie Callender's SmartLabel and the Food Lion listing for Mrs. Smith's, so the label on the box you buy is the final reference.

Try Aurascan

See what is really in the food you buy.

Common questions

Is Mrs. Smith's or Marie Callender's pumpkin pie better?
Neither pie is better on every panel line. Per 1/8 pie, the Food Lion listing for Mrs. Smith's shows less added sugar (23 g, 47% DV vs 30 g, 60% DV) and fewer calories (310 vs 360), while Marie Callender's shows less sodium (280 mg vs 350 mg).
Mrs. Smith vs Marie Callender pie?
Per 1/8 pie, Marie Callender's shows 360 calories, 30 g added sugars and 280 mg sodium, while the Food Lion listing for Mrs. Smith's shows 310 calories, 23 g added sugars and 350 mg sodium. Both list milk, eggs and wheat, and both carry no high fructose corn syrup and no artificial dyes claims.
Is Marie Callender's pumpkin pie healthy?
The label facts alone do not establish whether this pie is healthy for any particular person, because that depends on diet and health needs. Per 1/8 pie, the panel shows 360 calories, 280 mg sodium, 6 g saturated fat and 30 g added sugars (60% DV).
Does Marie Callender's pumpkin pie have dairy?
Yes, the label marks milk under Contains, from nonfat dry milk in the filling (per 1/8 pie, 128 g). The pie is not labeled dairy-free.
Is Mrs. Smith's pumpkin pie gluten free?
The Food Lion listing does not describe Mrs. Smith's pie as gluten free, and it states 'Contains: milk, eggs and wheat.' Wheat flour is the first crust ingredient in that listing.
Is carrageenan in Mrs. Smith's pumpkin pie safe?
Carrageenan is listed in the filling of Mrs. Smith's pie on its Food Lion listing. That listing and the Marie Callender's SmartLabel make no health statement about carrageenan, and the Marie Callender's pie does not list it.

Sources

  1. Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label (fda.gov)
  2. Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie SmartLabel (UPC 612781101410) (smartlabel.conagra.com)
  3. Marie Callender's Pumpkin Pie product page (mariecallendersmeals.com)
  4. Mrs. Smith's Original Flaky Crust Pumpkin Pie (frozen, 37 oz box) retailer listing (foodlion.com)

In this series

Related guides

Try it on your own groceries

Scan your next label with Aurascan

Point the camera at any ingredient list and get the same evidence-graded read you see here.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

See a sample result

Get food recall alerts + a weekly digest

An email when a food recall is announced, plus one weekly roundup of label news and new guides.

We email a confirmation link first - nothing is sent until you click it. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy